Analogy Of The Sun Essay

2000 words - 8 pages

Plato is most renown for his written interpretations of his teacher, Socrates. It is within the sixth book of The Republic in which an important analogy comes to sight; the analogy of the sun. Many questions regarding this analogy have been orbiting the minds of great thinkers, one being whether or not the analogy makes any sense. The obvious answer is yes, it does make sense, but before we dive into this topic, a proper explanation of the allegory of the sun is needed.

The origins of the allegory comes from a conversation between Socrates and Glaucon, Plato’s older brother. Within this discussion, Socrates brings forth the idea that the sun represents the good, and that the sun is ...view middle of the document...

The good is responsible for the existence of all objects, the existence of forms, essentially the cause of everything coming to be in the visible and intelligible realms. (Reeve & Miller 199-200)

When dealing with intellect, a quote from the sixth book of The Republic comes to mind. Socrates is believed to have stated, “the latter is in the intelligible realm in relation to understanding and intelligible things, and the former is in the visible realm on relation to sight and visible things.” (Reeve & Miller 199) He essentially means that the good is the source of intelligibility. The Oxford Dictionary describes intelligible as the ability “to be understood; comprehensible.” (Intelligible n.d.) Using this definition and relating back to the argument that the sun represents the good, the good is seen as a source for light and visibility, more so a source for intellect, it is easy to see that the sun makes the visible realm comprehensible due to its giving of light and visibility. If it were night, you would not be able to establish what certain objects are, they would seem rather imperfect. Socrates tells Glaucon to think of it as the same with the eye of the soul. He states “when it focuses on something that is illuminated both by truth and what is, it understands. But when it focuses on what is mixed with obscurity, on what comes to be and passes away, it believes and is dimmed, changed its belief this way and that, seems bereft of understanding.” (Reeve & Miller 199) An easier example could simply be as follows; a plant that you find in the middle of the forest during the night. If you were to stand several feet away from the plant, you would be unable to see it. The object you are viewing will appear a little distorted, maybe disfigured, and possibly animal like if you were not that experienced with plants. However, with the sun and much more light, you can see the object from a few feet away and can make it out to be a plant. Do not get this mixed up with the theory that just because you can not properly see the object, it does not exist. The plant still physically exists, however when it is shrouded by darkness it is hard to point out certain characteristics of the object, it is nearly impossible. Even though things are there and visible, their true perfect form cannot be seen without light. Therefore, it can be seen that the good, by producing light and visibility, acts as a source of intelligibility.

Now that the good has granted us light and visibility, allowing us to see objects clearly and understand what they are, the next thing that comes to the plate is knowledge. As defined in the Oxford Dictionary, knowledge is known as “facts, information, and skills acquired through experience or education; the theoretical or practical understanding of a subject.” (Knowledge n.d.) Some philosophers will argue that knowledge is a priori (knowledge that is independent of any experiences, knowledge that you are born with) while...

Other Papers Like Analogy Of The Sun

What Is Knowledge Essay

1595 words - 7 pages , I would say, to acquire knowledge of object x is to capture and assimilate the essence of object x with our cognition. Knowing is not only grasping the essence, but assimilating the essence with oneself. I would compare assimilating an essence tantamount to a moment of enlightenment, which very much resembles Plato's analogy imagery on confrontation of the sun. I also agree

Ayer Essay

1149 words - 5 pages Examine the contribution that two of the following may make to the study of religious language * Analogy * Symbol and myth * Language games Religious language has been around for years and two of the contributions that relate to this are analogy and language games. Religious language is used to talk about religious ideas for example the existence of god. The Vienna circle can up with the idea of the verification principle and


1347 words - 6 pages . Walk around the class (read the questions and summary) to check students’ understanding. If necessary, ask questions g. Cell city analogy worksheet (Appendix 3): this allows students to relate cell organelles and functions into real life situation. h. Classwork/homework: Cell Crossword puzzle, student are expected to make their own cell analogy 8. Create their own cell analogy 9. Draw the picture of

Articles Of Confederation

325 words - 2 pages this day’s reading assignment. When reading today’s assignment, the provisions in the Articles of Confederation appear to be Thomas Jefferson’s ideal constitution. Jefferson’s farmer is the analogy I thought of when reading the Articles. Independent farmers are people who provide for their own subsistence, according to Jefferson, and a community that instills this philosophical principal is positioned to become a virtuous society. The unlimited


342 words - 2 pages planets which are also in our solar system, but they are unimportant compared to the nine major planets. In this paper I will discuss the planets and how they are each unique. Mercury which is the planet that is closest to the sun is the first planet I will discuss. Mercury is the smallest of the inner planets. It is speculated that the heat from the sun made it impossible for the gases present to become part of the planetary formation. The

Phil Study Guide

844 words - 4 pages Lau Tzu (Laozi): - Taos analogy to water: water takes all shape, water doesn’t compete, it does nothing yet there’s nothing it can do, takes no form, all forms can be taken. - Taos analogy to uncarved block: un-carved block is preconceived, preconceived thoughts/values makes it harder to respond to present situations. - Taos analogy to valley spirit and the female: nonbeing “spirit of value with divine female”. Value -> space-> spirit

Annotated Bibliography

298 words - 2 pages Annotated Bibliography Garrison, Jr., Joseph M. The Past and Present in “That Evening Sun”. Studies in Short Fiction; Summer76, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p371, 3p. Joseph Garrison created a fairly accurate interpretation of the perceptions presented in the story of “That Evening Sun.” He clearly presented his explanations and arguments for why he believed that the story is written more from the boy Quentin’s point of view rather than that of the older


726 words - 3 pages the speaker attacks Professor Miller personally rather than the actual argument for faculty salary increase, by blaming him that he is being selfish for increase in salary. In this sentence, cold-heart is ad hominem associated with scientists. * Slippery Slope Adverse consequences because of a change in policies, processes, actions or law, is usually known as slipper slope. For example: We have to stop the tuition increase! The next

Evaluation Of Disembodied Existence

1251 words - 6 pages worldly desires such as sex and love of money. The best way Plato puts his point across is through the analogy of the charioteer, the charioteer is displayed as our reason in which controls and maintains the carriage, the two horses are spiritive and appetite. Appetite is often depicted as black as this is the one leading us away from our ultimate goal and leads the soul stray whereas the white horse, our spirit, is the one who keeps us on the

Data Management

406 words - 2 pages and teams. Work for both projects is to be contracted to outside consultants. Two managers at XDM, one assigned each to Agentfox and Mulder, prepare RFPs and send them to several contractors. The RFPfor Agentfox includes a statement of work that specifies system performance and quality requirements, a desired completion deadline, and contract conditions. As an incentive, the contractor will receive a bonus for exceeding minimal quality measures

Mencius On Human Nature

349 words - 2 pages analogy of the four germ sprouts, Mencius states four potentials that are hardwired into human genes; “From the feeling of commiseration benevolence grows; from the feeling of shame righteousness grows; from the feeling of courtesy ritual grows; from a sense of right and wrong, wisdom grows. People have these four germs, just as they have four limbs”. These views on human behavior point more toward modern psychology/sociology because they accept

Related Essays

Explain Plato's Analogy Of The Cave

1384 words - 6 pages the released prisoner. Thinking in new ways can be painful; this is clearly represented by the jagged ascent out of the cave. Once outside the prisoner would find it harder to take in the new world he saw around him, the bright lights around him would daze him. At first the prisoner would focus on the shadows made by the sun but soon be able to see the objects fir what they really are. This is an important bit in the analogy because what is being

Critical Essay Sun Tzu The Art Of War

1021 words - 5 pages * Critical essay - based on annotated reviews and module material. * * You should critically explore the thoughts, ideas, implications and applications of your chosen ‘thinker’ in theory and/or practice. * Sun Tzu Sun Tzu is traditionally believed to be the author of The Art of War. This was an influential ancient

Philospohy Essay

1050 words - 5 pages Explain Plato’s analogy of the cave. Plato, a famous Greek philosopher who wrote the ‘Allegory of the cave’ attempted to answer some philosophical questions (Why are we here? What is reality?). Plato tells the ‘Allegory of the Cave’ as a conversation between him and his teacher, Socrates, who inspired may of Plato’s philosophical theories. The Analogy of the cave is one of the most famous passages in Plato’s republic. Imagine prisoners being

Miss Essay

8170 words - 33 pages ' (asserting/stating by analogy). We do this a great deal of the time with our language. A stone, for example, is a lump of rock. Logically, the phrase 'a stony look' would be absurd, but everyone knows the facial expression referred to. Equally, it would be ridiculous to ' interpret the sentence, 'My heart sank like a stone' equivocally. Aquinas points out that the word 'good' can be applied to God and human beings, but it means different things. John