Battle Of The Contraries: Glory Of War Or Gory War In De Forest’s Miss Ravenel’s Conversion From Secession To Loyalty

1002 words - 5 pages

Battle of the Contraries: Glory of War or Gory War in De Forest’s
Miss Ravenel’s Conversion From Secession to Loyalty
According to Jay Martin, John William De Forest presents many “contraries” in the spirit of writing a novel realistic in its portrayal of Americans and American life (Martin 30, 33). Using a central historic theme of the Civil War, the two opposing contraries are romanticism and realism, or “antiromantic[ism]” (Martin 31). De Forest reveals both the Civil War’s antiromantic horrors and romantic strengthening by hardships the soldiers face in Miss Ravenel’s Conversion From Secession to Loyalty.
De Forest casts aside traditional romantic tendencies of Civil War ...view middle of the document...

De Forest’s agenda reveals itself by both intentional and unintentional methods. He wrote his main accounts of the war during the time of war, and not later as many others have. His writing less likely suffers memory distortion or the golden glaze of nostalgia, or as Michael Adam writes, tales “softened by time” (Adams 224).
Opposing all of deglorifcation of battle, however, is De Forest’s glorification of what battle has done to the characters, in particular, Colburne’s men. Colburne feels great “pride to the hardihood of soul” all of the “hardships had given to [his] soldiers” (323). They have been “tempered to steel by hardships [and] by discipline” (323). Their experiences have made them stronger.
It can also be said that in a very Puritanical way, he believes in strength through suffering (Cecil 356). In McConnell’s review of De Forest’s A Volunteer’s Adventures, a Union Captain’s Record of the Civil War, he interprets De Forest’s writing as those of one who tires of the “monotony of camp life and wishes for a baptism of fire” (McConnell 376). He narrates Colburn as one “exalted by the fever of bodily weariness and spiritual sorrow,” his heart and soul heavy with the death of his mother and all the suffering he has seen firsthand in the Civil War (71). Only in the midst of pain can a person seem to find their greater self. He progresses from the once shy individual, unsure of himself in the beginning of the novel to a man of confidence in the end of the novel.
At the novel’s conclusion, Colburne portrays the war’s best while Carter shows the worst. Colburne passed through and triumphed De Forest’s trial by fire and in a rather romantic fashion is rewarded with the love of Lillie. Carter on the other hand, falters in this hellish trial and fails, a drunken Colonel blaspheming a few seconds before his mortal wound (409).
Why does De Forest present these contraries? He writes that “[y]ou must learn to accept the...

Other Papers Like Battle Of The Contraries: Glory Of War Or Gory War In De Forest’S Miss Ravenel’S Conversion From Secession To Loyalty

Terrorism Vs War Of Terror Essay

474 words - 2 pages I believe that the wars inAfghanistan and Iraq are strikingly similar to the Vietnam war and thus will affect the generation the same way as the Cold War. The war in Vietnam lasted from 1961-1973 and the War on Terror has lasted from 2001-today in 2012. It is still going on. At the time,Vietnam was the longest war in history but it will soon be surpassed by the War on Terror. When the Cold War began, younger children and teenagers who were

Critical Essay Sun Tzu - The Art Of War

1021 words - 5 pages * Critical essay - based on annotated reviews and module material. * * You should critically explore the thoughts, ideas, implications and applications of your chosen ‘thinker’ in theory and/or practice. * Sun Tzu Sun Tzu is traditionally believed to be the author of The Art of War. This was an influential ancient

Reflection On The Speech Of Civil Liberties And War

383 words - 2 pages Remembrance(DOR) commemorating Executive Order9066 which ordered 120,000 Japanese Americans to concentration camps during World War II. From the first event in 1981, DOR has come to present some of the defining issues facing the Japanese- American community and a time to reflect on our history in the United States. Staring with the debate over redress/reparations to support for American Muslims today. DOR has provided a forum for the San Jose

How Far Do You Agree With The View That Stalin’S Foreign Policy Was A Major Contributing Factor To The Emergence Of The Cold War In The Period 1945-50?

852 words - 4 pages how pivotal Stalin's expansionist views were in the outbreak of war, his zeal and resolve to control the continent conjured fear in the Americans and source T shows that Stalin would use any means necessary. Such actions so as to cease control in Europe would not go without reaction from America and actions such as the communist coup d’état in Czechoslovakia would not go unnoticed. They were met with resistance; both the Marshall plan and Truman

The Battle Of Ombre In Alexander Pope's The Rape Of The Lock

919 words - 4 pages The Battle of Ombre in Alexander Pope’s The Rape of the Lock The card game of Ombre was created in Spain in the early 17th century. There are many various names and various ways to play this card game. Ombre is a three-handed trick game and consists of four players, but only three active players. In Alexander Pope’s The Rape of the Lock, Pope uses this card game to create a sort of mock-heroic effect in a sense of a sort of battle that is

To What Extent Was The Civil War A War Over Slavery

1544 words - 7 pages  which made large land holdings  profitable. In general opinion this unhumanitarian situation was the reason of Civil War.  But...  Was it that clear?  Was the only reason to war combat for human rights and abolish slavery?  Was it heroic battle to give Africans in United States independence and stop possibility  to buy or sell humans?  Absolutely; it was not only about this.    As we know, lower South region (seven states) declared

War In Afghanistan

5695 words - 23 pages change the status quo condition into its favour, which may start from a minor confrontation and end up in a major conflict or a full-blooded war in the future. Polarity is one of the most significant aggravators of the conflicts that aggravate the amount of violence as well as conflict behaviour between the warring states. If the warring states belong to two different International power systems, belonging to conflicting ideological systems

Battle Of Fort Pillow

1420 words - 6 pages from her home and hanged in front of her family.# Clearly, the idea of Union separatism allowed for a general attitude of “no quarter” that was blind to race, gender, or social position long before Ft. Pillow. Texas was not the only southern state to encourage and enforce this disposition; embitterment toward Union sympathizers was spread across the Confederacy and struck the hardest in areas of Virginia, North Carolina, and Tennessee. While

The Cold War

739 words - 3 pages different geographical areas and age groups. The first two respondents were husband and wife. The husband is sort of a history buff from Canada and his wife is from Florida. Both of them are in their forties, so neither one of them studied the Cold War in during school. What they did have to say, was interesting. They both described the Cold War as a “superiority battle between two countries trying to prove which one was the most powerful when dealing

The Persian Gulf War

718 words - 3 pages The Persian Gulf War Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein ordered the invasion and occupation of neighboring Kuwait in early August 1990. Alarmed by actions, fellow Arab powers such as Saudi Arabia and Egypt called on the United States and other Western nations to interfere. Hussein refused United Nations Security Council demands removed from Kuwait by January 1991, and the Persian Gulf War began with a massive U.S. led air offensive known as Operation

How Far Was The Labour Party Election Victory In 1945 Due To The Changes In Social Attitudes During The Second World War?

969 words - 4 pages significant leftward shift in public opinion and the amount of state intervention that the public wanted. The success of total war showed the public that state involvement was a positive thing and could actually benefit the public. The massive extension of State control, regulation and planning seemed to have led to full employment and a sense of working together for a common goal. Many of the poor population was benefitting from the wartime rationing

Related Essays

Heroism In Stanley Kubrick’s Films Paths Of Glory And Full Metal Jacket By Comparing The Visual Styles And Narrative Structures And Offer Insight Into Kubrick’s Views On War

1810 words - 8 pages army in either war, the French side in Paths Of Glory, and the American side in Full Metal Jacket. Perhaps this is how Kubrick kept his films simple. There are no excuses shown whatsoever for war. It is a fearful, dark environment; Kubrick never allows war to look good in any way, shape, or form. No matter what, war is war, and war is inherently wrong. War is shown as being beyond discomfort. Whether in the grim, dark trenches or in a

How Universal Are The Principles Of War?

1200 words - 5 pages truth represented from Field Marshal Erwin Rommel quote “The battle is fought and decided by the quartermasters before the shooting begins.” Supplying food for soldiers, feed for horses or the strengths of modern war; petroleum, oil, and lubricants, logisticians have understood that victory is impossible without them. Great leaders of history like Frederick the Great to Napoleon to Patton understood the link between their operations and logistics

War Of Independence Essay

788 words - 4 pages piece. They realized that it is ridiculous for a king to rule a country or colonists from a this far distance of 1000 miles and then to make them pay tax even if they have no say rights and say in the government. His strongest point, however, is that the British’s control over the colonies is self-serving. He says that England is only looking after its own interests even if it means that the colonists have to suffer and if they do not separate from

Cause And Outcome Of War 1754 To 1815

1654 words - 7 pages Cause and Outcome of War 1754-1815 Abstract This paper will compare and contrast the French and Indian War, American Revolution, and the War of 1812. All three wars were fought over land or expansion in one form or another. The French and Indian War was fought because both countries believed they had the right to the Ohio River Valley. This caused Britain to tax the colonist and place restrictions that led to the American Revolution. The