This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Business Law 2 Case Study 1

427 words - 2 pages

Case Study 1 – Millan V. Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc.
Plaintiff: Maria Millan
Defendant: Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc.
Appellant: Maria Millan
Appellee: Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc.

History of the case
Trial Court: Dean Witter won. The broker was found 85% liable and the firm was found to be 15%.
Lower appellate court: Dean Witter won.
Overall winner: Decision upheld, the broker was found 85% liable and the firm was found to be 15%

Maria Millian sued both her son and Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc. for negligence, gross negligence, conversion, and breach of fiduciary duty. Maria Millian opened two brokerage accounts with Dean Witter Reynolds, ...view middle of the document...

stole money from Maria Millian by deceiving her. Because Miguel opened fraudulent accounts in the name of Maria Millian and wrote checks payable to cash, and because the company did not verify the signatures, Millian sued for negligence, gross negligence, conversion, and breach of fiduciary duty.

Defendant’s theory:
Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc. was not fully responsible for the fraudulent acts committed by Miguel because he was not acting within the scope of his position at the firm ultimately resulting in monies being stolen from Millian’s account.

Legal issue:

Should the brokerage firm be held vicariously liable for the fraudulent acts of one of its brokers, even though the customer defrauded was his mother?
The holding of the court:
Trial court: No
Lower Appellate court: No
Appellate court ruling: No

I believe that this case was decided correctly because the individual that committed the fraudulent acts was Miguel and although he was working for the firm, he indeed made those decisions himself. It was not Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc. that forged signatures and wrote fraudulent checks out of the accounts of Maria Millian’s. However, with this being said, I do feel that Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc. should be held somewhat liable due to the firm not always following their own company policies, this helped Miguel in committing these acts because if the firm were to have followed their company policies, these fraudulent acts may have been avoided or caught sooner and could have been dealt with accordingly.

Other Papers Like Business Law 2 - Case Study 1

Case Study 2: Translating Talent

315 words - 2 pages Case Study #2 1. How does Sol y Canto define its business? Identify the offer, the target market, and the product and delivery capability. - They define their business by creating music and performances that move, delight, excite and connect the audience with Latin American culture. Connecting individuals in general; Hispanic and Non-Hispanic through a shared experience of music. Their target market ranges from small children to senior

Business Law Week 1 Busn 429

566 words - 3 pages Week 1 Assignment Business Law Name Course ID Date School Even though not all laws are defined by legislature, general rules have been put in place to maintain a legal standard. Being established by the English almost a thousand years ago, it moves with the times and allows changes to come in and set a new precedent or change what

Gb519 Case Study Wk 1

1008 words - 5 pages Unit One: Case Study (MIP) Kaplan University – GB519 Measurement and Decision Making March 2010 What is the ROI for MIP based on original estimates? • Operating assets ( development costs were $140 million • Sales ( annual operating income was expected to be approximately $25 million ROI for MIP = 25 million / 140 million = .18% What is the ROI if Richard Lawrence’s new revenue projects are used

Business Ethics Case Study - Tylenol

1406 words - 6 pages bottles, the company ordered a national withdrawal of every capsule. (This showed that no matter the cost to the company, customer safety was priority number one.) • They were candid. J&J used both public relations and advertising to communicate their strategy, keeping customers informed and in the loop. – They issued a national alert telling the public not to use the product. – They set up a 1-800 phone line so people

Nt1210 Itt Tech Case Study 2

441 words - 2 pages Switch Name Vendor Cost Reason Dell CompUSA $325 High performance, lifetime warranty, wiring closet solutions, desktop connectivity Cisco Axiontech $565 Lifetime warranty, software, layer support 2,mounting hardware Juniper Discount Computer Super Store $850 High performance, lifetime warranty, layer 2 & layer 3, low power consumption NT1210 Case Study 2 1. 2. Our company had to upgrade the NIC, the reason for this is they needed

Agricultural Business Feasibility Study (Chapters 1-3)

6762 words - 28 pages Chapter 1: BUSINESS CONCEPT A) Business Name The mushroom culture is already gaining its popularity in Pangasinan, Philippines, specifically in Urdaneta City. As a vegetable, it is being added as one of the ingredients in some of Pangasinan delicacies. However, due to lack of planting materials and knowledge, the production of mushrooms is still limited. With a lot of suggestions about the name of the business, the researchers have

Case Study 1: Motion Picture Industry

1467 words - 6 pages MANAGERIAL REPORT Case Study: Motion Picture Industry Assignment 1 Prepared By: Table of Contents Introduction 3 Executive Summary 3 Data and General Analysis 4 CONCLUSIONS 12 Integrity Statement 13 Works Cited 13 Executive Summary In this report we will show, via descriptive statistics, how independent variables appear to contribute to the success of motion pictures.  Using data collected from a sample of 100

Management 530 Week 1 Case Study

389 words - 2 pages MGMT530 – Conference Decision Week 1 Case Analysis Template Katrina Johnson Management 530 Managerial Decision-Making 1) Define the decision problem? This case is about an Accounting System User’s Conference that was to be held in New Orleans, LA. However, due to Hurricane Katrina, the hotel is no longer able to accommodate the conference. Management must decide whether to move the conference to a different venue or change the

Case Study: Procter & Gamble Business Strategy

795 words - 4 pages Case Study: Procter & Gamble Business Strategy Summary: Procter & Gamble, the internationally known company that was founded in 1837, is the producer of various everyday household goods. Over the many years of manufacturing, marketing, and distributing products, the company developed many business strategies and adjusted them accordingly when needed. The first strategy Procter & Gamble used was to have mass production of goods out of their

Case Study: The Business Strategies Of Qvc

2536 words - 11 pages Case Study: The Business Strategies of QVC Group 2: Michael Kenlan Karen Maxwell Brian McKearney Tara Murphy Zach Smith MIE 480, Spring 2010 Dr. Washington Abstract John Segal founded QVC in West Chester, Pennsylvania in June of 1986, two years behind the launch of its predecessor, the Home Shopping Network. Despite this later emergence onto the cable scene, QVC surpassed its competitor quickly and has

Example Of Business Ethics Case Study (Indonesian)

926 words - 4 pages Case Taken from: Jennings, Marianne Moody. 2008. Business Ethics: Case Studies and Selected Readings. United State of America: Cengage Learning The Finance Club at Harvard University is a prestigious organization for Harvard MBA students. The student members have the opportunity to interact with public officials like Senator William Proxmire and business executives such as Bruce Wasserstein. The Finance Club also serves as a network for

Related Essays

Case 1 2 Essay

401 words - 2 pages Case 1 - Exercise 2 King and Company PRO FORMA AUDITOR'S REPORT To The Board of Directors of The Lakeside Company, We have audited the accompanying balance sheet of The LakeSide Company as of December 31, 2011, and the related statements of income, retained earnings, and cash flows for the year then ended. These financial

Case Study 1

1264 words - 6 pages perspective of value, from an economic, market, and relevancy perspective (Bowersox, 5). Without improving value, a firm can become obsolete and lose business. Under a new purchasing agent, GARD looks to improve its efficiency of operations. Currently the firm works within a 10 day delivery, plus or minus 2 days, which is a 5 day service window. If this is the industry standard, GARD will not have a competitive advantage over other similar firms and

Case Study 1 Ihrm

1160 words - 5 pages zxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmq wertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuio pasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghj klzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbn mqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwwerty uiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdf ghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm Case Study: 1 Spanning the Globe 9/26/2011 Tasha Smith Keller School

Business Unit 2 Assignment 1

4430 words - 18 pages Recruiting and retaining the right people Edexcel BTEC L3 Business Studies Unit 2 Business Resources I have gained an internship at my school, and I will spend 6 weeks supporting the human resources department. Currently the most experienced member of the human resources department, is away on long term sick leave. The school is looking to make sure I can help maintain its ability to recruit the right staff and control their financial and non