This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Case Analysis

983 words - 4 pages

Law
Case analysis
MONTGOMERY ELEVATOR COMPANY, a Delaware Corporation authorized to do business in the State of Colorado, Petitioner, v. Brenda GORDON, Respondent
No. 79SC207

Supreme Court of Colorado
619 P.2d 66; 1980 Colo. LEXIS 770
November 10, 1980
Parties:
Brenda Gordon:
Plaintiff in the first instance Appellant in the second instance
Montgomery Elevator Company (Elevator maintenance company)
Defendant in the first instance Appellee in the second instance
Westinghouse Electric Corporation (Elevator manufacturer company)
Defendant in the first instance
Facts:
Brenda Gordon was injured when she attempted to exit from an elevator in the Hilton Hotel in Denver, where ...view middle of the document...

So based on the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, which adopted the contributory negligence, plaintiff had liability for her injury, so she failed in the first instance for her negligence.
Second instance:
The court of appeal reversed and remanded to the district court for a new trial, holding that the elements of res ipsa loquitur had been established with the adoption of comparative negligence.
The district court is affirmed. So both the appellant and appellee shared the responsibility according to the degree of their negligence.

Reasoning:
Res ipsa loquitur.

1. The event is the kind, which ordinarily does not occur in the absence of negligence.
2. Other responsible causes, including the conduct of the plaintiff and third persons, are sufficiently eliminated by the evidence.
3. The indicated negligence is within the scope of the defendant's duty to the plaintiff.
4. The plaintiff is free from any contributory negligence or other responsibilities.
First instance:
In a trial to the jury, Gordon relied solely on the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur to establish the defendants' negligence. Aside from the defendants' admissions in their answers and their opening statements, Gordon's testimony at trial was the only evidence presented on the negligence issue.
According to the evidence, the former three requirements are established. However, the court adopted forth requirement before the effective date of the comparative negligence on July 1, 1971; the court adopted the contributory negligence. The plaintiff can’t win this case because she had the contributive negligence for her injury.

Second instance:
 The first element of res ipsa loquitur was applied, because appellee breached its duty.
 The second element of res ipsa loquitur was applied, because appellee, rather than someone else, was more probably than not, responsible for the negligence.
 The third element of res ipsa loquitur was applied, because the evidence shows that appellee had been responsible for the maintenance of the elevator since 1961, and a mechanic on duty “ practically all the time.” Therefore, absent introduction by the appellee of evidence to the contrary, it is more probable than not that the malfunction...

Other Papers Like Case Analysis-

Case Analysis

3399 words - 14 pages managerial finance function is defined and differentiated from economics and accounting. The chapter then summarizes the three key activities of the financial manager: financial analysis and planning, investment decisions, and financing decisions. A discussion of the financial manager’s goals—maximizing shareholder wealth and preserving stakeholder wealth—and the role of ethics in meeting these goals is presented. The chapter includes discussion of

Case Analysis Summary

2519 words - 11 pages Case Analysis Summary This class requires a clear understanding of how to prepare for a class discussion on assigned cases. It’s important to learn how to do this to be successful not only for this class, but also if you want to become a successful manager. I should be able to come up with a good argument for what I believe is the correct plan of action that needs to take place for whatever managerial situation. I hope to be able to effectively

Hershey Marketing Case Analysis

302 words - 2 pages Hershey Marketing Case Analysis The Hershey Company Hershey’s customer base consists of wholesale distributors, chain grocery stores, mass merchandisers, chain drug stores, vending companies, wholesale clubs, convenience stores, dollar stores, concessionaires, department stores and natural food stores. The company has made significant changes over the past decade to strengthen its relationships with these customers. Primarily, the company

Case-In-Point Analysis

1016 words - 5 pages Case-In-Point Analysis (Name Here) SCI/362 February 19, 2012 Michael Eslinger, Ph.D. Case-In-Point Analysis Global warming and food web declines in Antarctica are affecting more than most would have thought. The krill population plays a major role in the cycle of life for many mammals in this area but also for migratory mammals. This paper will expose food web declination in relation to global warming as well as what could have

Mexico Case Analysis

1052 words - 5 pages are looking at the problem in the point of view of SAGARPA Ministry (Agriculture and Rural Development Ministry of Mexico). With this in mind, we are trying to formulate the best possible solution or courses of action that will aid to the problems of Mexico. We will be using theories and policy like the Harris-Todaro Model to have an in-depth analysis of the economic setback of this country. With this, we will be able to recommend a good

Wilkerson Case Study Analysis

960 words - 4 pages . Wilkerson’s existing cost system is a tradition value based costing systems. Direct costs are based on the price. Overhead costs are figured proportionately to the direct labor costs at the rate of 300%. 4. Develop and diagram an activity based cost model using the information in the case. Provide your best estimates about the cost and profitability of Wilkerson’s three product lines. What difference does your cost assignment have on reported

Executive Shirt Case Analysis

1714 words - 7 pages OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT EXECUTIVE SHIRT COMPANY CASE Q.1) Compute the following quantities for the current production process as well as for Mike’s and Ike’s plans, assuming the plans are implemented as described in the case. Solution: Current batch processing Sales for the Executive Shirt Company are constituted of only a few basic styles and colours. Hence the company has

Case Study Analysis

1307 words - 6 pages ABC Case Study Analysis Introduction A quote from a President of the United States of America, “never put off till tomorrow what you can do today” (Jefferson, 1817). The phrase holds true today especially in the entertainment industry where the slogan is: the show must go on! Don’t put off what you can do now for later. Background The job of the campus recruiter is to hire potential employees after successfully completing indoctrination

Case Study Analysis

1563 words - 7 pages Case Study Analysis Paper: The Importance of Preparation Rosa Edwards COMM/215 November 30, 2014 Rebecca Kinney Introduction Carl Robin is a new recruiter for a company called ABC, Inc. He has been working with the company for 6 months and is now performing his first recruitment for Monica Carroll’s, Operations Supervisor. Mr. Robins have 15 new trainees scheduled to begin working on June 15th. Mr. Robins is to make sure that the new

Case Study Analysis

1453 words - 6 pages She Kennedy Case Study Analysis COMM/215 03/09/2015 Gloria Reeves Introduction As the consultant for ABC Co., I noticed several issues the company needs to address in order to be successful. The new recruiter for ABC, Inc., Carl Robinson, hired 15 new trainees in the month of April and scheduled them for orientation for June 15th. They are scheduled to start working by the month of July. Monica Carrolls, the Operations supervisor

Case Analysis On Hp Vietnam

779 words - 4 pages A CASE ANALYSIS OF HEWLETT – PACKARD COMPANY IN VIETNAM SUBMITTED IN IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT THIRD TRIMESTER A.Y. 2013 - 2014 SUBMITTED BY: ARANZASU, ALANNETE G. – MBA BUENAVENTE, MARIDOL – MBA LIMJOCO, MONET – MBA LIWIDJAJA, JASON NATHANEIL – MBA VILLARAIZ, MARIA VERONICA – MBA SUBMITTED TO: PROF. ROWENA GALANG (April 18, 2014) I. TIME CONTEXT The problem was observed during the

Related Essays

Case Analysis

267 words - 2 pages Case Analysis 1 Case Analysis MT311: Business Law I Scott Strauss October 5, 2010 Case Analysis 2 Case Analysis Thomas Baker and others bought new homes from Osborne Development Corp. and they sued for multiple defects in the houses that were purchased. When the homes were sold, it was paid for in a new home warranty program administered by Home Buyers Warranty (HBW). The company enrolled the homes with HBW and it paid a fee and

Case Analysis

554 words - 3 pages Case Analysis Outline Viewpoint Any person who is a decision maker or who is cap[able of recommending a solution as mentioned in the case or any consultant hired to recommend a solution. Time Context Generally, it delineates the take-off point of the analysis. I. Problem Statement This defines the perceived problem presented in the case and which is the object of the analysis. It may be presented

Case Analysis 1988 Words

1988 words - 8 pages Week 3: Case Analysis Assignment: Apple Inc. Geraldo Moraes DeVry University BUSN-412 Business Policy Professor Raef Assaf CASE ANALYSIS ASSIGNMENT: APPLE INC. Apple Inc. designs, makes, and markets mobile communication and media gadgets, PCs, convenient advanced music players, and offers a mixed bag of related programming, administrations, peripherals, organizing arrangements, and outsider computerized substance and applications (Dess

Case Analysis 911 Words

911 words - 4 pages Case Analysis #2: Patty – Anorexia Nervosa After reading the case example of Patty, complete the questions below in a readable, colored font. These questions are designed to help you apply the theoretical explanations for the disorder. We will be discussing these during class as well as expanding upon them so you might benefit from bringing a copy of your responses to class for the discussion. 1. Many people do not understand the full