This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Company Law Essay

1718 words - 7 pages

Does the decision in Island Export Finance Ltd v Umunna represent the law in Singapore?

To determine whether the decision in Island Export Finance Ltd (IEF Ltd) v Umunna represent the law in Singapore, the application of the common and statutory law will be used. Upon applying the right principles, the decision will represent Singapore law.

Resignation to take up a corporate opportunity
Singapore law states that the court held a director breached of his duty by taking up the opportunity if he resigns from a company to take up a corporate opportunity without the company’s permission where (i) the resignation was prompted or influenced by a desire to acquire the opportunity ...view middle of the document...

This does not represent Singapore law because since IEF is hopeful for further orders shows that it is interested and hence, falls under the definition of corporate opportunity. Furthermore, it is through his directorship that led him to know of such opportunity. Thus, U may be held in breach of his duty under Singapore Law based on the definition of corporate opportunity and his directorship that led him to acquire the opportunity.

Improper use of information
Under Companies Act, Section 157(2) prohibits officers or agents of the company from making use of improper information that by virtue of their position to gain, either directly or indirectly a benefit for themselves or other person. Generally, the definition of ‘improper use of information’ refers to the use of trade secrets or confidential information without company’s approval.

In Umunna case, he was not held liable for the information which he acquired as managing director. This decision does not represent Singapore law because Umunna’s knowledge of the potential market is confidential information and he had used it without the company’s permission to gain the contracts which could belong to IEF Ltd. Thus, following Singapore Law, Umunna would have been held liable for the improper use of information.

In contrast, in Umunna case, Hutchinson J held that the knowledge of potential market forms part of his general fund of knowledge and expertise, thus Umunna was not held liable. I agree with Hutchinson that if the information forms part of his general knowledge, it would be unreasonable to hold the directors accountable for the exploitation of the knowledge. However, a potential market discovered by the company itself should be classified as confidential information otherwise it is easy for an employee to gain benefits from insider information anytime.

In my opinion, the decision in Umunna case does not represent the Singapore law to a large extent. It shows a more flexible approach as compared to PMA which represented the law in Singapore. In conclusion, Singapore law is very strict and makes it difficult for a director to escape from breach of fiduciary duties.

Discuss when (if ever) a director can or should be able to appropriate to himself a business opportunity under the statutory and common law regime for the directors’ duties in Singapore.

In the following, we will discuss the common law regime followed by statutory when a director can or should be able to appropriate to himself a business opportunity in Singapore.

Common law
1) General Law – Conflict of duty and interest
The general rule in Singapore is that a director must not place himself in a position where there is possibility of a conflict between duty and interest of the company without company’s permission. Upon approval granted through a resolution of the shareholders in general meeting, a director can usurp the business opportunity.

2) Usurp business opportunity

Other Papers Like Company Law

Financial Acumen Essay

326 words - 2 pages Creating Financial Acumen 1. Companies are in business because they want to achieve profits. In this regard, it is necessary that there is a solid financial acumen no matter what business the company is engage in. Being a paralegal, for instance, means that I work for a law firm. The firm should be aware of its finances in order to retain the best lawyers, paralegals, and other staff. If the firm does not have financial acumen, its workers are

Diabetic Impact Essay

948 words - 4 pages principles to assist their associates in making the right decisions and acting with integrity. These principles are, to always act with integrity. Lead with integrity, and expect others to work with integrity. Follow the law at all times Be honest and fair. Reveal and report all information truthfully, without manipulation or misrepresentation. Work, actions, and relationships outside of your position with the company should be free of any

State Of Confusion

931 words - 4 pages State of Confusion BUS/415 March 21, 2012 State of Confusion The State of Confusion passed a law that requires trucks, semi-trucks, and tow trailers that uses its interstate freeways to use a bravo-style truck tow hitch. The problem with this hitch is that only one company makes these types of truck hitches within the State of Confusion. The consequence of this law is that any drivers or truckers who want to drive their way through

Marketing Plan

271 words - 2 pages the company and members, and between the members themselves. Section 33(1) is a codification of the common law principle. The articles of association is a contract between the company and its members. This was held by the courts in Hickman v Kent of Romney Marsh Sheep Breeders’ Association (1915) and Quins & Axtens Ltd v Salmond (1909). In Hickman, the company’s articles of association provided that if there was any dispute between the company

Virtual Organization Employment Law

516 words - 3 pages Running Head: VIRTUAL ORGANIZATION EMPLOYMENT LAW Virtual Organization Employment Law- Kudler Fine Foods University of Phoenix Virtual Organization Employment Law- Kudler Fine Foods Kudler Fine Foods is a company that employ’s people of all ethnic groups throughout the company’s three locations. Being that Kudler Fine Foods has such diversity under its employment, some of the rules and regulations set by the company may pose a potential

The Role And Function Of Law

734 words - 3 pages intention of growing both in its industry and community. Law provides some degree of good faith dealings and reliability in planning and transactions (Melvin, 2011). A California medical aesthetics company is launching a new product line into the marketplace and has acquired personnel from an industry competitor, not without significant legal application. Federal and state statute have outlined the forum in which this company must comply

Precision Parts

1123 words - 5 pages Precision Part Inc. is looking to do business with other international companies. One of the countries that Precision part is interesting in is Germany. In order to do business in Germany, it is important to understand their business ethics and laws. By understanding the law at hand, it would give Precision Part Inc. a better understanding on how Germany conduct business and also to make sure the company is ethical. A few international

Short Essay

894 words - 4 pages population was that before the waves begin that the corporate law department would be looking into the policies that were in place to ensure that everything was done Fairly, Ethically and Legally. I have to say, whether I had my job or didn't, the process has been just that. The company Home Depot and Hurricane Andrew, two names in The State of Florida that have gone down in history. Boatright (2012) states in part when Hurricane Andrew struck in August

Sample Will

970 words - 4 pages that nature. In criminal law, the accountability has to be “Beyond a reasonable doubt” in order for anyone to be convicted of the crime. This means that there has to be a considerable amount of evidence towards the person or company, and that they question the guilt very little or not at all. In this type of case, if the jury doesn’t come up with a unanimous decision of guilty or not guilty, it causes a mistrial in the case. In a civil

State Of Confusion

934 words - 4 pages make a law to benefit them. Paulette opinion it is not constitutional to make a law about a person’s personal property. A truck is someone’s personal property and if for any reason, it is the company chooses to use a different hitch other than the B-type hitches. Tonya Trucker owns a trucking company and for the state of Confusion not let her drive through is not constitutional. In the U.S. Constitution, it states each state to honor others

Business Law

1812 words - 8 pages Articles of Association. For these companies, removing a director will be a relatively straightforward matter, usually requiring the board or majority shareholder to simply serve written notice on the director in question. For companies which do not have these powers enshrined in their Articles, company law provides a statutory procedure to allow shareholders to remove a director by passing an ordinary resolution at a general meeting of the company

Related Essays

Role And Functions Of Law Paper

957 words - 4 pages ROLE AND FUNCTIONS OF LAW PAPER Role and Functions of law paper If one wants to be successful in business and society then understanding law is important. Laws control social behavior, and social behavior helps society run more proficiently. Laws also help with ethical standards and give a person a hire expectation of

The Role And Functions Of Law

911 words - 4 pages company, this author had direct experience with common law when holding clients responsible for contract violations. In most cases, the law specified that the signed contract was binding and that the company had the right to pursue the individual for damages to the vehicle and/or money owed. Administrative law gives the executive branch and independent government agencies the right to exercise authority. “Pursuant to congressional mandates, these

Garfinkle Essay

289 words - 2 pages disagree with Garfinkle’s concept of a free market that anyone should have the right to buy out any company he wishes. Markets are confused about a free market. Businessman will sell off part of company for quick profit and close down factories, thus throw people into unemployment. Other workers will dissatisfy with our boss, the company can’t make the money so the company will bankrupt. b- The government should pass a market law clearly to

Ellen Degeneres Sues Clean Clothes For Misappropriation And Right Of Publicity For The Use Of A Look Alike Model For The Slacks Advertisement. Clean Clothes Countersues For Product Disparagement....

315 words - 2 pages he three parties involved in this business matter are Ellen DeGeneres, Clean Clothes Company and Joseph A. Bank clothing store. Ellen DeGeneres is suing Clean Clothes Company for using her likeness and dance in a commercial video without her permission. The law that Ellen is presented in the court is misappropriation and right of publicity against the Clean Clothes Company. The Clean Clothes Company is countersuing Ellen DeGeneres for product