This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparison Of Duffy’s ‘Lizzie, Six’ And ‘Oppenheim’s Cup And Saucer’

1441 words - 6 pages

Comparison of Duffy’s ‘Lizzie, Six’ and ‘Oppenheim’s Cup and Saucer’
In this essay I will be comparing two poems by Carol Ann Duffy; ‘Lizzie, Six’ and ‘Oppenheim’s Cup and Saucer’, both of which explore similar themes of sexuality, yet they portray this in a very different manner.
As mentioned, ‘Lizzie, Six’ and ‘Oppenheim’s Cup and Saucer’ both portray a sexual persona. However, there is a huge difference between the natures of these relationships. Already from the title ‘Lizzie, Six’, we get the impression that this poem is presenting an underage girl. This, as well as the simplistic, childlike replies in the second line of each stanza, particularly ‘to play in the fields’ shows the ...view middle of the document...

What’s interesting is how Lizzie’s line is always the second line in the stanza, highlighting how she is trapped unable to escape by the persona. Her being the second to speak also shows how her opinions are valued less than the persona in question due to their authority. This structure also implies the girl’s lack of physical space to speak, as for every three lines her abuser has, she is only permitted one, indicating her abuser is also much larger and therefore older.
‘Oppenheim’s Cup and Saucer’ is similar in that it too follows a set structure throughout. It is split into four couplets, indicating their togetherness and romance in the relationship of the couple, a complete contrast to that in ‘Lizzie, Six’. Duffy also used enjambment to further demonstrate the ease of their relationship, and how naturally they go together. Like in ‘Lizzie, Six’, there is little rhyme in ‘Oppenheim’s Cup and Saucer’, however the rhyme of ‘spine’ with ‘mine’ really emphasises how they are the same because of their gender, and their feelings for each other. The mention of ‘her breasts were a mirror’ also shows the symmetry and this creates a sense of intimacy and emphasises how the narrator of the poem has only positive memories of the relationship. This symmetry is directly contrasted in ‘Lizzie, Six’ with Duffy italicisation of Lizzie’s speech, which really distinguishes between the two voices and shows the difference between their characters. Even the appearance of the italic letters Lizzie’s vulnerability and fear of the other voice, as they actually lean and cower away from the rigid letters of the first voice.
Imagery is very important to both poems, and they both really rely on phallic imagery to represent the nature of their relationship. However, again, there are distinct differences between how this phallic imagery is used, and the resultant effects are quite opposite. In ‘Oppenheim’s Cup and Saucer’, the use of the euphemism and phallic imagery of ‘we drank the sweet hot liquid’ creates the feeling of comfort and relaxation, further highlighting the comfort the narrator feels in their relationship. In contrast, the use of phallic imagery in ‘Lizzie, Six’ creates the opposite effect, with ‘I’ll give you wood’ coming across as threatening and cold, its bluntness truly portraying the harshness and abuse Lizzie must suffer. It’s also quite shocking the way Duffy twists Lizzies meaning of ‘wood’ as in forest into something much more mature, something someone so innocent should not understand.
Duffy also uses many ambiguous terms to emphasise her point and create a different twist as well, often creating very interesting imagery. Her use of ‘fur’ in ‘Oppenheim’s Cup and Saucer’ not only reflects the shock of there being fur in a teacup, linking back to the title and also emphasising the shock of a homosexual relationship, but it also again uses phallic imagery to represent pubic hair. Opening the poem with ‘She asked me to luncheon in fur’ therefore...

Other Papers Like Comparison Of Duffy’S ‘Lizzie, Six’ And ‘Oppenheim’S Cup And Saucer’

Comparison Of Hamlet, The Lion King, & Rosencrantz And Guildenstern

733 words - 3 pages , Rosencrantz and Guildenstern betray Hamlet. 12. In both Hamlet and Rosencrantz and Guilderstern are Dead, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, Hamlet’s childhood friends, can understand Hamlet better than anyone could. 13. In both Hamlet and Rosencrantz and Guilderstern are Dead, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern discuss how they might probe Hamlet for discovering the cause of his supposed madness. 14. In both Hamlet and Rosencrantz and Guilderstern

Comparison Of Different Types Of Media And The Impact Of Online Media In The Hotel Industry

1177 words - 5 pages Comparison of different types of media and the impact of online media in the hotel industry With more and more people are becoming internet savvy, communicates with the customer through Internet is more efficient and cost effective. Online and social media open up a new way to distribute promotion messages to potential customers. The aim of this paper attempts to analysis the difference between traditional media and online media and how

Individualism Contrast And Comparison To Collectism

1120 words - 5 pages Individualism versus Collectivism Aungee Stevenson Beulah University Marketing MBA Professor Scott September 24, 2011 Individualism vs Collectivism America when remembered by its history was a place built upon freedom and was the logic of vast opportunities within a new country with innovation as its' first name. For more than 100 years America has been priding itself upon engaging and welcoming people from all over the world

Julius Caesar Anthony And Brutus Comparison

405 words - 2 pages Compare and contrast Antony and Brutus. In the play Julius Caesar there are two main characters, Brutus and Mark Anthony. These characters have major differences between them. They are both opposites to each other. Brutus was an honest but naive man while Mark Antony was a persuasive, deceptive, and ambitious man. Antony used the art of deception to control people such as in his funeral speech for Julius. Antony used his words to turn the

Comparison Of The Poems “The Flea” And “If We Must Die”

1160 words - 5 pages Comparison of the poems “The Flea” and “If we must die” Many authors use images to convey a message from their theme in their work, as well, to enhance the meaning behind their theme. In the poems “The Flea” by John Donne, and “If we must die” by Claude McKay, both authors use images of animals to convey the theme of death, but each poem uses a different approach to death, one being symbolized by two lovers being united through a flea using a

The Evolution Of Tqm In The Manufacturing Sector: A Comparison Of Current Practice In Japan And China

1479 words - 6 pages The evolution of TQM in the manufacturing sector: a comparison of current practice in Japan and China. TQM has many definitions which are influenced by individual interpretations of businesses or academics’. However for the purposes of this study TQM is defined as “the involvement of all of a company's managers and employees in making sure that its products and services are all of a high standard and exactly as designed” (Cambridge Business

Comparison Between The Unix And The Windows 2008 Servers

1747 words - 7 pages Comparison between the UNIX and the Windows 2008 servers Instructor Keating   ECPI University CIS305 Advanced UNIX Administration   June 15, 2013 There are many reasons that I choose this speaking about the UNIX server verses the Window 2008 server but mainly it was the fact that I had no idea how this server worked and why it was so important. At first when I heard of UNIX it didn’t seem important at all in fact all I could remember

Comparison-Contrast Paragraph Between Cell Phones And Landline Phones

4859 words - 20 pages Chapter I Project background This Chapter deals with the proposed Business Name, Title of the Study, store location, Business Logo, Brief Description of the project, General Objectives, Research Methodology and Survey. Proposed Name of the Business The future entrepreneurs come up with Golden Glow as the name of the business. The word “Golden” describes the color of deep fried empanada. The word “Glow” comes from how vegetables can

An Overview Of The Canadian Health Care System With A Comparison To The United States Heath Care System Canadian And American Health Care

1310 words - 6 pages Running head: An Overview of the Canadian Health Care System with a Comparison to the United States Heath Care System Canadian And American Health Care Parween Nooruddin Stratford University Abstract The reason for this exploration paper is to look at healthcare systems in two very progressed industrialized nations: The United States of America and Canada. The principal piece of the exploration paper will concentrate on the portrayal of

Of Mice And Men

387 words - 2 pages Mikayla Weinke 04/23/14 Advanced Lit. and Comp. Mr. West Symbolism is a key concept throughout the novel, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck. Though there were many examples of symbolism, mice were paramount throughout the book, even included in the title of the novel. They were symbolic of the struggle with helplessness. The mice and Lenny were helpless and acted without the ability to understand consequences they may face because of

Of Mice And Men

761 words - 4 pages Michael Emminger Ms. Wanczuk English 9 Honors Period 3 11/21/13 Character Analysis Essay A time of sickness, bankruptcy, and underground liquor runs; the 1930’s were a devastating time in which our protagonists lived. Of Mice and Men is a classic book by John Steinbeck. Published in 1937, this tale shows the adventures of two poor men, George and Lennie, who are suffering in the Great Depression. The book goes through a portion of their

Related Essays

Westin Resorts And Six Sigma Essay

2042 words - 9 pages Westin Resorts and Six-Sigma Six Sigma’s impact in the service industry, high quality products and performance are a top priority for any company. By implementing total quality management systems, businesses are seeking to improve the effectiveness of their performance. “Six Sigma is a process created to eliminate or reduce variations in the operation process”(Jacobs & Chase 301), often used in manufacturing industries. Through Starwood

Comparison Of Beowulf Film And Book

704 words - 3 pages that there is evil inside of him. Moreover, in the poem Beowulf is loyal, even when he is an old man. He dies protecting his people was his duty, he does this all along despite incredible odds against him. In the film Beowfulf is disloyal. For instance, when Grendel’s mother promises him that as long as “the cup” remains in her lair, nothing will be able to harm Beowulf and he will be a great king if he helps her to have another son, he accepts and

Comparison Of Odysseus And Athena As Liars

744 words - 3 pages Comparison of Odysseus and Athena as liars Deception, or the act of deceiving or defrauding, is a prominent theme in the Odyssey. Though inherently dishonest, deception can be used to gain information and knowledge. Different characters (and people) use it different ways. This essay will establish that, whereas Odysseus uses deception to help him progress from Nobody back to Odysseus, king of Ithaca, Athena does so to keep her identity secret

Jc And Vp Comparison Essay

1187 words - 5 pages 'veni, vidi, vici' (I came, I saw, I conquered) Could Julius Caesar have made a statement like it in the 21st century? Julius Caesar was one of the greatest in history, many say. Even though he was not the first emperor of Rome, becoming the emperor he showed all victories achieving it. He conquered many city-states and give the peoples much better lives. He started in Spain with great lessons he learned personally and for his career. But how