Employment At Will Doctrine Essay

1167 words - 5 pages

Jazzelynn Daigle
January 27, 2013
LEG 500
Assignment 1
While the Employment-At-Will Doctrine allowed employers to terminate an employee for any reason or no reason at all, every situation between employees and employers is not so cut and dry that this may take place automatically. The following scenarios discuss situations where exceptions may apply and steps before termination may need to be taken.

Skills, Competence, and Abilities
In a situation where the employee is unable to learn basic job functions, it is easy to understand how termination would be the very first course of action. The most basic understanding of the Employment-At-Will Doctrine would allow for the employee to ...view middle of the document...

This way, there is evidence that both the employer and employee have the same expectations for what the employee should be able to do after a certain amount of time.
The other exception that may be applied in this situation is the “Covenant-of-good-faith” exception which suggests that there is a certain “just cause” standard to which employers should be held. In this particular scenario, it means that if the employee is terminated, the employer should have to show that the employee’s shortcomings justify termination.
Since the employee is unable to perform the basic job functions after months of training, the next step would be a one-on-one conversation with the employee to find out what their struggles are and if there is any way to accommodate the employee so that they can perform better. This is another conversation that should be documented and put in the employee’s file. That would show evidence that the employer was even willing to make exceptions to their own practices in order to assist the employee. This conversation would also include a warning that if performance did not improve, the employee may be terminated as a result.

Management, Behavior, and Performance
In this scenario, where the employee throws tantrums and seems to be threatening a wrongful discharge lawsuit if any action is taken regarding her violation of the attendance policy, it may be necessary to have a discussion with two authoritative figures of the company (one to act as a witness) to go over expectations for employee behavior and attendance. Like all such discussions with the employee, this conversation should be documented and serve as a disciplinary warning. Since it is impossible to tell exactly what the employee means when she says she knows “what to do,” in the event that her employment is terminated, such documentation would legally protect the company in case she tries to claim she was wrongfully discharged.
This situation is an example of why employee handbooks are essential. A handbook would outline the attendance policy as well as acceptable and unacceptable work behavior. Having an employee’s signature as evidence that they agree to the policies and standards outlined in the handbook would serve as further evidence that the employee was aware that they were in violation of those policies.

Labor and Laws
For the part of the scenario where the employee seems to be attempting to unionize her colleagues, no disciplinary action can be taken legally except for the...

Other Papers Like Employment-At-Will Doctrine

Chapter 4 Essay

1355 words - 6 pages protest on Boeing’s side would be proving when the negotiations for employment took place, which would probably tie up the case in the protest process for an extended period of time. 3. Even if it is not included in the contract, the Termination for Convenience clause is still valid. The Christian Doctrine says that the Termination for Convenience clause is inherent to government contracting therefore it does not have to be present in the

A Case Analysis On Corporate Criminal Liability

4662 words - 19 pages servants / agents. The doctrine of identification supposes a situation where the crimes committed by the company can be directed towards the directors / managers of the company who are the directing mind and will of the company and they are held liable for the acts committed by a separate legal entity namely the company. Vicarious liability is a reverse proposition where the negligent agents of a servant/ agent during the course of his employment

Hrm 742 Individual Assignment 1

381 words - 2 pages , persons with disabilities and members of visible minorities. If Wilson Brothers obtains a large federal government contract, the organization will be obligated to comply with this legislation, and must ensure equality in the workplace. Wilson Brothers will be required to: • Determine if all four designated groups are fully represented at every level of their organization • Identify and eliminate employment barriers for any of the four designated

Case Brief Unit 5 Rodman V New Mexico Empl. Sec. Dept

1020 words - 5 pages benefits based on her misconduct connected with work under §51-1-7(B). Ms. Rodman appealed to The Appeals Tribunal of the Department of Employment Security. The Tribunal found based on evidence that Ms. Rodman had willing disregarded her employees request to improve her conduct at work despite her contentions that she could not stop a third party from their actions. The hearing officer deemed Ms. Rodman’s actions as unreasonable and constituted


3351 words - 14 pages were the additional defining points of a states “employment-at-will” doctrine. However, “Employment-at-will” is more times than not, the best defense for an employer, provided the employer is not engaged in a contract with the employee (such as the state and federal government and labor unions). The Bureau of Labor Statistics states: In the United States, employees without a written employment contract generally can be fired for good cause, bad

Employment Laws

1501 words - 7 pages adverse employment action is not motivated by discriminary intent or administered in a discriminatory manner. Employers must be cautious when discipline or discharging an employee covered by any one of the expanding list of federally protected classes--- age, race, color, national origin, disability, religion, sex, or status as a Vietnam-era or special disabled veteran. Although under the at-will doctrine an employer need not articulate any reason

Medical Malpractice And Informed Consent

1064 words - 5 pages scope of her employment. According to respandeat superior, an organization can be held vicariously liable, even if they are not at fault in any way, if one of their employees or agents performed a negligent act while acting in the scope of their employment. Dr. Green is an independent physician that has a written agreement with the Plan stating that Dr. Green is not an employee or an agent of the Plan. Since patents are not provided this

Business Law

1767 words - 8 pages  administrative justice and tribunals council. Employment tribunals were created as Industrial tribunals by the Industrial Training Act 1964. Employment tribunals were set up at the same time that the United Kingdom enacted the first of a series of employment rights laws. The Tribunals were intended to give employees a quick , inexpensive and informal way of enforcing those rights. The idea was that the traditional court system was too expensive for

The Cold Ar And Us Deplomacy

2401 words - 10 pages since it did not feature any form of military action. The countries in this war possessed nuclear weapons and any form of war would have led to serious destructions on both divides. The relative calm between these countries was sometimes followed by high tensions, which would have emanated into a war but did not (Gottfried & Reim, 2003). The following essay will look at what the U.S. did during that time, as well as summarize the situation that

Ethical Hacking Essay

1017 words - 5 pages (Johnson, 1994). From most hacker's perspective, freedom of information includes the right to source codes and the programs themselves. This freedom also includes the right to access information stored on a computer network. At times, hackers argue that the freedom of information doctrine gives them the right to have unrestricted access to computer accounts, passwords and email. At this point, the ethical position of hacking has become "system

Rel 133 What Is A Belief System

1228 words - 5 pages good or bad these standards will make an indelible mark on the individual. The values are usually first imprinted through the parent and reinforced with outside influences such as a church. The parent begins with the values and morals handed down to him or her through their own religious upbringing. Even though the child may have been exposed to the religion throughout his or her childhood it is not a guarantee they will stay with that doctrine

Related Essays

Employment At Will Essay

4737 words - 19 pages Running head: Employment At Will Employment at Will: Relationship between Societal Expectations and the Law Stephanie K. Walker Averett University BSA535 Business Law January 2014 Abstract This paper analyzes the relationship between the survey conducted by the Department of Labor in New York and Syracuse areas and the existing law. The survey reviews the law regarding the dismissal of at

Leg 500 Essay

1427 words - 6 pages Organizational Behavior Kofi Osei Tutu Law, Ethics & Corporate Governance: Employment At Will Doctrine Dr. Meredith Brasca February 2, 2014 Employment-at-will [EAW]: “when an explicit agreement of contractually binding terms of employment is absent, the employment relationship exists only so long as both parties will it to continue. That is, either party is free to end the relationship at his or her will. Moreover, the relationship

Legal Issues In Reduction Of Workforce

1728 words - 7 pages category defined as employment-at-will. The employment-at-will doctrine states that unless employees contracted for a definite period of employment (such as one year), employers were able to discharge them without cause at any time. FastServe would be able to terminate these employees without notice as long as no violations of federal statutes such as the Civil Rights Act, Age Discrimination in Employment Act, or the Fair Labor Standards Act occur

Business Administration Essay

2454 words - 10 pages . | | | | |2. Has the employer-employee relationship changed over the course of time? Describe the factors | | | | |that support your determination. | | | | |3. Is Mary’s release legal under the doctrine of employment-at-will? Explain why or why not