Enron Scandal Essay

1475 words - 6 pages

Phoenix or vulture
after acquiring the rover group from british aerospace in 1994, german automaker bmw set about carving up the assets of the group :the land rover division was sold to ford motor company in the united states, and the reborn mini business was established as a subsidiary of bmw based in the uk. the remaining assets were sold as mg rover in 2000 after continued losses and declining market share. having recouped some of its purchase price with the land rover sale to ford for 1.8 billion, and with an expected contribution of positive revenue from the mini subsidiary,the assets of mg rover were sold for a nominal $20 in may 2000 to a group of businessmen led by ex-rover chief ...view middle of the document...

in april 2005,mg rover confirmed that it had received a 6.5 million 'stop gap' loan from the british government, but the funds proved insufficient to maintain the company as a viable operation,and it ceased trading on may 20,2005, with debts of 1.3 billion and a further 6000 jobs lost.

the closure of mg rover marked the end of british mass production of automobiles,but the story of mg rover was about to take a dramatic turn. with suspicions of poor financial management at the company ,the british government commisioned a report by the national audit office (nao) into the collapse of the company. that report,issued in march 2006,revealed that the seniour executives of the 'phoenix consortium ' (soon to be referred to as the 'phoenix four', had,along with chief executive kevin howe, received total compensation in the amount of 42 million over the 5 years in which the group operated mg rover. while the compensation (around 80 million) may be small by american bailout standards, the phoenix consortium had been welcomed as saviours of mg rover and had negotiated aggressive cost cuts based on its popularity and its commitment to rescuing britain's last volume carmaker.

the nao report prompted an investigation by the serious fraud office (sfo) over misuse of taxpayer funds (for the 6.5 million loan from the government). the investigation took four years to complete and cost the british taxpayers another 16 million on top of the 6.5 million loan that was now worthless. the sfo report concluded that the phoenix four had done a much better job of structuring their compensation and pension plans than they had of running the company,but found insufficient grounds for criminal prosecution.the phoenix four maintained their innocence throughout the investigation and condemmed the sfo report as 'a witch hunt against us and a whitewash for the government.


1)why would bmw sell millions of pounds of assets for 10 and lend the buyer an additional 427 million?
2)why would saic want to buy 70 percent of a company that was losing money for 1 billion?
3)with compensation packages already locked in,do you think the executives were committed to making the saic's or tata motor's deals work?
4)if mg rover had been successful in winning a 120 million loan from the government rather than a 6.5 million loan, would the outcome of the sfo investigation have been any different?
5)the phoenix four maintain they did nothing wrong. how would you defend their conduct from a business athics perspective?
6)what do you think the outcome should have been for the phoenix four?

selepas memperolehi kumpulan rover dari aero angkasa British pada tahun 1994, jerman pembuat bmw menetapkan tentang ukiran aset kumpulan: rover bahagian tanah yang telah dijual kepada syarikat motor ford di negeri-negeri yang bersatu padu, dan perniagaan mini dilahirkan semula telah ditubuhkan sebagai anak syarikat...

Other Papers Like Enron Scandal

Enron Essay

5885 words - 24 pages ENRON COMPANY Foundation, History and Decline 1. Enron company 1.1 What is Enron 1.2 History and Organization 1.3 Main business units 1.4 Main characters 2. Enron scandal 2.1 The decline 2.2 Causes 2.3 Consequences of the scandal 2.4 Punishment 2.5 Enron's insurances 3. Enron reconstitution 3.1 Cleaning up after the fall 3.2 Restructuring Enron 3.3 The future (and present) of Enron 3.4 Preventive measures 1.1

Aaaaaa Essay

2155 words - 9 pages Sherron Watkins—Revelations of a Letter Who Is Sherron Watkins? Sherron Watkins gained fame as the so-called “whistle-blower” in the Enron accounting scandal. “Enron hid billions of dollars in debts and operating losses inside private partnerships and dizzyingly complex accousnting schemes that were intended to pump up the buzz about the company and support its inflated stock price.” Watkins wrote two letters, one anonymously, to Enron’s

Evaluation Tools

289 words - 2 pages Agenda of final presentation: Company background Scandal (video) Unethical behaviors Business ethics Lesson learned Ten things your company can do to avoid being the next Enron Earlier today, a salesman who works in Iowa called you and told you about an expe- rience he had last week. One of his customers placed a small order of about $1,500 worth of product from corporate headquarters. The home office immediately shipped

Csr And Psychopathy

1792 words - 8 pages , but are still in the same positions of power and able to continue their transgressions. Here are some interesting highlights of the last decade: Enron scandal (2001): Andrew Fastow the CFO of Enron along with Kenneth Lay the Chairman and Jeffrey Skilling the CEO develop an off­balance­sheet mark to market fraud that loses $11 billion and bankrupts Enron. It is the largest bankruptcy reorganization in US history at the time. They are charged with

10 Major Accounting Scandals

5070 words - 21 pages was being conducted. Investors were conned into believing that Enron was highly profitable by making it appear that the company’s energy commodities were heavily traded. The following were the highlights of Enron's accounting scandal: Enron's selling activities were made to appear "robust" by way of "round-trip" trades and press releases about fictitious trade deals. Substantial bank borrowings were channeled through bogus companies created by

The Price Of Unethical Behavior

1675 words - 7 pages The Price of Unethical Behavior MGT7019-8 Ethics in Business Laura M Brooks July 21, 2013 We as a society have assumed companies in whole have been ethical in doing business. It wasn’t until Enron in 2001 that the public has become more aware of business activities. Shortly after Enron, Tyco International caught the public eye. One must first have an understanding of what it is to be ethical and moral. Once there is an understanding of


1006 words - 5 pages 1970. In 1974 the first cash dividend was declared for Wal-Mart. They provide the shareholders of the company an annual dividend and they are paid quarterly for their investments. This has stayed this way since 1974 and has not faltered or changed. Wal-Mart seems to me to be a company that will never fail the community, public, shareholders and employees. They have been faithful and honest and have never been involved in a scandal that I have

Accounting Paper

2420 words - 10 pages assets, however as Enron collapsed, these intangibles were nowhere to be seen. While the firm’s collapse was a result of a complex creative accounting scandal rather than a poor evaluation of intangible assets, it highlighted the dangers that accompany a lack of a standardized valuation and recognition system for intangible assets Following the Enron collapse, in 2002, the American government passed the controversial Sarbanes-Oxley Act, which called

Ethics Of Stock Option Backdating

2131 words - 9 pages -money and of value to the holder. (Investopedia 2013) In simplest form a $90 option in today’s value was granted at $60 as of a previous period, the immediate gain would equate to $30 per share. Introduction The media and society has systemically panned backdating as ‘unethical,’ ‘damaging,’ and superficially placed the practice in the same category of the unethical behavior which lead to the collapse of Enron. (Raiborn er al. 2007, p.1

J.P. Morgan Chase Faces Arising Issues

3096 words - 13 pages J.P. Morgan Chase Faces Arising Issues Taylor A. Akinmoladun National American University Abstract J.P. Morgan Chase Bank has found their way into a lot of turmoil in recent years. Each having its own affect of the bank’s reputation. The famous Enron scandal is hard to forget, and some of J.P. Morgan’s executives are still being sued over the bank’s relationship with them, even over a decade later. Back in 2005 the bank made an interest rate


6737 words - 27 pages Corporation to deliver video on demand [Li 2000]. The deal quickly died, even before Enron crashed and burned in the giant accounting scandal. The subsequent arrangements left Enron feeling less than satisfied, and it broke off the relationship. ―From Enron‘s standpoint, the main reason for discontinuing the relationship had to do with content,‖ said Enron spokeswoman Shelly Mansfield. ―We just felt that, through the exclusive relationship, we

Related Essays

Enron Scandal Essay

376 words - 2 pages since the ‘garbage in, garbage out’ principle also prevails in financial markets, public trust in the functioning of financial markets has declined as a result of major financial reporting scandals involving Enron, Tyco, WorldCom, Parmalat and others. Also, massive overvaluations of equity that occurred in the second half of the 1990s and in the early 2000s have been singled out as being caused by misinformation and manipulation of financial

Sarbanes Oxley Essay

992 words - 4 pages Kyle Reed MGT 309 Dr. Williams 09/06/2015 Research Paper – Enron and Ethics in Financial Reporting Table of Contents Cover Page – Page 1 Table of Contents – Page 2 Introduction – Page 3 Statement of Problem – Pages 4-5 Analysis of Problem – Pages 5-6 Conclusion – Pages 6-7 References – Page 8 Introduction A major scandal that still resonates in financial markets today was Enron’s bankruptcy. The business environment of the

The Ethics Of Enron Essay

1414 words - 6 pages became the sixth largest company in the world that provided energy (Enron Fast Facts, 2015). It was due to Ken’s ambition to turn the stable business from a pipeline business into an energy powerhouse (DiLallo, 2015) and the reported “error of judgment” in the handling of the debt in the overstatement of profits between 1997 and 2000 by the company’s auditor Andersen (Enron: The Real Scandal, 2002), that Enron accrued its overwhelming debt and

Ethics Essay

613 words - 3 pages translate into increased profits and will then satisfy the stakeholder's needs and agendas (Marquis, nd). ETHICS PAPER 3 OVERSTEPPING ETHICS The most popular corporation that over stepped ethics was Enron Corporation. This scandal happened in 2001 and cost stakeholders and employees 38 billion dollars in