This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Justice What’s The Right Thing To Do?By: Michael J. Sandel

649 words - 3 pages

Justice- What’s the right thing to do?By: Michael J. Sandel |
Chapter 2: Utilitarianism |

Bentham's explanation of Utilitarianism is “the right thing to do is whatever will maximize utility.” (Sandel p.g.34) which means that the right thing to is always whatever produces the greatest amount of happiness and whatever is necessary to prevent unhappiness. Suppose you are walking and someone stops you to take a poll; they ask you if you rather have an animal center where you can pet animals, or if you would have a school for special children. Which would you choose? Most people would choose the school because there are children involved, but according to Bentham and his theory, there should be an animal center because it is what makes people happy. In our scenario, what makes people happy are animals therefore he would say to build a pet center because the people would be the happiest, hence maximizing utility.

...view middle of the document...

(Sandel pg. 41) On the other hand we have the example where it is justifiable to torture a man to give out information of a bomb that can kill thousands of people. In this example Utility is acceptable, but if the “terrorist” is not willing to speak up, where utilitarianism draws the line is having to torture the family so they can talk. If there are thousands of lives at stake, Sandel tells us utility will be acknowledged as doing the greater good and cause pain rather than not torturing and risking lives.

The second approach in the book is John Mill’s concept of utilitarianism. Mill’s concept is basically to do anything that makes you happy, as long as you do not harm others. Sandel goes on to say “Mill believes it is possible to distinguish between higher and lower pleasures”. (Sandel pg. 53). But when you ask yourself, what are higher pleasures? Well, my higher pleasure would be to lay on my sofa and relax before cooking, or just sit in the balcony and read a chapter of my favorite book. Those are higher pleasures as they are what makes you most happy, and most importantly, are not harming others. Mill tell us his liberty principle, where we can ban religion if a mass number of people don’t believe in it, as this will make the happy. To the minority of the people, as Sandel said, it will cause pain and suffering, This is cause for a disagreement in as Mill’s liberty principle is do whatever makes you happy.

In conclusion, having two different approaches to what utilitarianism is, give us many examples as some may be right and others wrong, depending on your point of view. Another philosopher, Immanuel Kant believed that “certain types of actions (including murder theft, and lying) were absolutely prohibited, even in cases where the action would bring about more happiness than the alternative.” (Kantian Ethics). In Kant’s theory we see another point of view of Utilitarianism, knowing there are thousands of views with utilitarianism, it is to one's discrete which theory to believe.

Works Cited
Justice: what’s the right thing to do?
Michael J. Sandel-Farar, Staruss and Giroux-2009
KANTIAN ETHICS
http://www.csus.edu/indiv/g/gaskilld/ethics/Kantian%20Ethics.htm

Other Papers Like Justice- What’S The Right Thing To Do?By: Michael J. Sandel

What's Feminism Got To Do With Economy? A Study Of The Practice Of Prostitution

5501 words - 23 pages nature of prostitutes as labourers must be carefully studied. I shall try to do so following Carole Pateman’s arguments.Pateman writes, “Prostitution is an integral part of patriarchal capitalism. Wives are no longer put up for public auction (although in Australia, the United States and Britain they can be bought by mail order from the Phillipines), but men can buy sexual access to the women’s body in the capitalist market. Patriarchal right is

Suze Says She Lives By Her Credo, “People First, Then Money, Then Things.” What Do You Think She Means By That? What Does That Mean To You? Please Explain Your Answer

255 words - 2 pages Suze says she lives by her credo, “People first, then money, then things.” What do you think she means by that? What does that mean to you? Please explain your answer. "People First, Then Money, Then Things," clarifies that when Suze says "People First," she means taking care of you first, not taking care of everybody else, as some people misinterpret it. You need to take care of yourself first. "People first" does not refer to your parents

Churchill Was Wrong And Misguided To Support Edward Viii In The Way That He Did. How Far Do These Sources Support This Interpretation?

607 words - 3 pages Churchill was wrong and misguided to support Edward VIII in the way that he did. How far do these sources support this interpretation? All three of these sources present a different image about Churchill’s approach Edwards’s situation. Overall Churchill’s view on the situation was the majority and most people were very angry with the King for trying to marry a divorcee. Sources B and C support the view that Church was misguided by telling us

Explain How You Would Communicate This Decision To Your Employees Or To Your Supervisors (Depending On The Decision You Have Selected) To Ensure That Future Situations Like This Do Not Occur Again. In...

326 words - 2 pages briefly explain the facts of the case, and the determination of the NLRB as to whether the employee was properly or improperly disciplined or terminated as a result of their use of Social Media to complain about, criticize, or publicly bash their company or boss. Provide the citation to the article you discover. (Use the term “concerted activity” in your query or search to help you find one of these cases.) (20 points) 2. Do you agree with the

How Far Do You Agree With The View That Stalin’S Foreign Policy Was A Major Contributing Factor To The Emergence Of The Cold War In The Period 1945-50?

852 words - 4 pages How far do you agree with the view that Stalin’s foreign policy was a major contributing factor to the emergence of the Cold War in the period 1945-50? Throughout the period 1945-50 there were a number of factors that caused the emergence of the cold war. One of these was Stalin and his aggressive foreign policy; another key factor to be considered is the American paranoia and resultant aggression at the time. Which of these factors was more

How Do Class, Gender, Sexuality Or Race Work In Relation To Taste Today? Using At Least Two Key Theorists Discussed On The Course, Explain How Ideas Of Taste Are Presented In Any Two Media Texts

2414 words - 10 pages MUD08243876Differences in cultural capital mark the differences between the classes” Pierre Bourdieu How do class, gender, sexuality or race work in relation to taste today? Using at least two key theorists discussed on the course, explain how ideas of taste are presented in any two media texts. The concept of good taste and class has always been a sensitive subject for those perceived as lacking

Explore The Idea, “Gender Equity Can Be Achieved By Being Sensitive To Problems Of Both Women And Men”

498 words - 2 pages GENDER EQUITY CAN BE ACHIEVED BY BEING SENSITIVE TOWARDS PROBLEMS OF BOTH MEN AND WOMEN Gender equality is, first and foremost, a human right. Women are entitled to live in dignity and in freedom from want and from fear. Empowering women is also an indispensable tool for advancing development and reducing poverty.One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman. No biological, psychological or economic fate determines the figure that the human

Answer The Following Question Based On The Reading By Bolman And Deal (Max 200 Words): Bolman And Deal Identify Three Common Fallacies Used When Trying To Understand Issues In Organisations. What Are...

794 words - 4 pages Pacific Islands and business planning, taking on a leadership role for the ongoing development and integration of McDonald’s business plan in Australia. b. Using the four functions as a guide, what activities does she need to undertake in managing the Australia operations of McDonald’s? MS Noble needs to undertake all of the managing functions described by her job. The first function is planning, this case study reports that she need to plan

How Does Knowledge Of The Foundations And History Of Nursing Provide A Context In Which To Understand Current Practice? Identify At Least Three Trends In Nursing Practice Demonstrated By The...

323 words - 2 pages How does knowledge of the foundations and history of nursing provide a context in which to understand current practice? Identify at least three trends in nursing practice demonstrated by the interactive timeline. How have these trends influenced your perspective of nursing practice? To understand the current practice of nursing, one must understand its history. Nursing is an art. One must have a passion for it. To be a nurse, one has to

Imanuel Kanmt And Abortion

310 words - 2 pages Immanuel Kant, a German philosopher who believes that all humans have certain dignity and commands to respect (Sandel, 2011). According to Kant, all behaviors and actions are done by people simply because they are the right things to do. Second, people do things based on whether it is moral rather than on any purposes. Kant would believe that an abortion is morally incorrect because it is not right to kill a person and it is considered as a

Embryonic Stem Cell Research

2739 words - 11 pages , Alzheimer's and multiple sclerosis” (Update: Stem Cell Research). It is unbelievable how many could be saved if cures for these diseases were discovered. There are very few people in this world that are not affected by one of these medical illnesses, whether directly or through loved ones. Finding solutions to these medical problems could change so many lives for the better. An example of what doctors and scientists could do is “generate

Related Essays

Right To The City By David Harvey

1968 words - 8 pages the conception of rights embedded therein. A different right to the city must be asserted. Those that now have the rights will not surrender them willingly: `Between equal rights, force decides'. This does not necessarily mean violence (though, sadly, it often comes down to that). But it does mean the mobilization of sufficient power through political organization or in the streets if necessary to change things. But by what strategies do we proceed

The Right To Cannibalism Essay

932 words - 4 pages Ragine Williams Ms. Wilson ENG 105 – 22 15 October 2013 The Right to Cannibalism In his essay, “A Modest Proposal,” Jonathan Swift reacts to the social problem faced by the Irish in 1720’s. Swift proposes that the babies of all the poor and desolate will contribute to the feeding, and partly to the clothing, of many thousands to improve Ireland’s economy and standard of living. He says this because many women kept having children but were

Euthanasia: A Horrible Thing Or The Solution To Torture?

553 words - 3 pages , should have the right to end their life. Firstly, the issue of quality of life plays a large role in the support of euthanasia. Lying in bed all day can be a form of torture within itself. Bed sores and boredom result from staying in bed, wasting away. Also, illness such as cancerous diseases and other sicknesses decline the quality of life. Of course, pain plays a role in this matter. It’s very difficult to function in everyday life when pain is a

The Right Time To Lose A Patient

774 words - 4 pages patient is a separate entity that requires the same attention and care. Having experienced loss so early on in my career, I will never forget the lessons I learned through this loss, and I do believe they will make me a better physician, who is more capable of caring for the whole person. For that reason, I believe there is a right time to lose a patient. To the patient I will never forget: thank you.