Meaning Of Meaning Essay

9460 words - 38 pages

2424A

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION: THE MEANING OF MEANING
RMIT University, Melbourne School of Accounting and Law, Symposium on Statutory Interpretation Chapter House, St. Paul‟s Cathedral 13 August 2009.

The Hon. Michael Kirby AC CMG

RMIT UNIVERSITY, MELBOURNE SCHOOL OF ACCOUNTING AND LAW SYMPOSIUM ON STATUTORY INTERPRETATION CHAPTER HOUSE, ST. PAUL’S CATHEDRAL 13 AUGUST 2009

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION: THE MEANING OF MEANING
The Hon. Michael Kirby AC CMG THE MAIN TASK OF MODERN LAWYERS Although we still describe ours as a common law system (to distinguish it from the countries of the civil law tradition), the label is now looking somewhat dubious.

The distinctive feature of ...view middle of the document...

Today there is nothing modest about the output of federal, State and Federal legislation. Every year it is contained in multiple volumes of printed paper. Happily, it is now more readily accessible by the

advances that have occurred in electronic technology. The shift in the expression of law from judge-made expositions to statutory and other rules has led to a number of changes in how statutory interpretation is undertaken.

First, by the mid-twentieth century, it was generally appreciated that the words of judges, written in their opinions, should not be subjected to the precise analysis appropriate to statutory and similar texts. Deriving the ratio decidendi of judicial holdings was recognised to be an art. Yet it was still commonly thought that securing the meaning of legislation was more of a science.

The explosion in the variety, detail and complexity of legislation has sorely tested this „scientific‟ theory. It has undermined the view that legislation has but one accurate meaning, which those bound by it only
2

need to search long and hard enough to find. The growth in the quantity of the written law has led to demands for plain English expression. However, it has also resulted in an appreciation that deriving the meaning of such laws presents „leeways for choice‟2, which courts, lawyers and others need to make in a transparent, consistent and principled manner.

Secondly, the growth in the size and importance of the laws made by and under parliament, has also led to changes in the rules applicable in Australia to the performance of statutory construction. Some of those rules have been enacted by parliament itself. Examples include the

federal, State and Territory statutory provisions requiring preference for a construction that promotes the purpose of legislation over one that does not3, and the authorisation of access by the interpreter to a wider range of extrinsic materials to assist him or her in this endeavour4. These statutory provisions effectively endorse moves that were already afoot in the judiciary of the common law both in England5 and Australia6.

SOME BASIC RULES OF APPROACH In addition to the encouragement of a purposive interpretation, legislative provisions have appeared designed to promote the

interpretation of legislation in ways consistent with enacted provisions
2

J. Stone, Social Dimensions of Law and Justice, (Maitland, Sydney, 1966), 649. Referring to the writings of Professor Carl Llewellyn, “The Normative, the Legal and the Law Jobs”, 49 Yale Law Journal, 1355 (1940. 3 See e.g. Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s15AA; Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic), s35(a). 4 See e.g. Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s15AB; Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic), r38(b). 5 Discussed J. Barnes “Statutory Interpretation” (Ch29) in I. Freckleton and H. Selby (eds.) Appealing to the Future (Thomson Reuters, Sydney, 2009), 721 at 736. See e.g. Forthergill v Monarch Airlines Ltd....

Other Papers Like Meaning Of Meaning

Socail Essay

267 words - 2 pages Menu Print Name Class CHAPTER 2 Date Graphic Organizer Activity Cultural Diversity The Meaning of Culture Complete the diagram by identifying the five components of culture. Define and give an example of each component. Then, below the diagram, summarize the meaning of culture. Components of Culture Component: Definition: Component: Definition: Example: Example: Component: Definition: Example

Symbolism In The Cask Of Amontillado

255 words - 2 pages Amontillado is the cask itself. Not only is it something spoken of in the story, it is also mentioned in the title, showing its importance. Its dictionary meaning would be a large barrel like container used for storing liquids. However, in the story it means so much more. Symbols usually have connotative meanings as well, which have particular meanings based on the context. In this story, the cask’s connotative meaning is much more important than

The Good Life As A Meaningful Life

1596 words - 7 pages be lived, we do not even have a clear definition for the phenomena in which we all participate. There are many attempts to give a definition to life and explain what a good or meaningful life is or should be. Each one of these outlooks which can be described as theories have their own pros and cons. If all the pros of the theories are chained together, will that give the ultimate meaning to life? Are broad theories like that of Aristotle pointing

Student

332 words - 2 pages interpretations: “An ambiguous answer”. 2. difficult to comprehend, distinguish, or classify: “A rock of ambiguous character”. 3. lacking clearness or definiteness; obscure; indistinct: “An ambiguous shape”. * Ambiguity: 1. Doubtfulness or uncertainty of meaning or intention: to speak with ambiguity. 2. The condition of admitting more than one meaning. 3. An ambiguous word, expression, etc.: a contract free of ambiguities. Examples of

Reflective Statement On Symbolism

306 words - 2 pages Theo Avery Mrs. Hamley IB English 11 8 October 2012 Reflective Statement on Symbolism Through the use of symbols/ motifs my understanding of the culture and context of Persepolis is furthered developed. Marjane Satrapi uses the title of each chapter to demonstrate emphasis on important symbols throughout the novel. It is crucial for the reader comprehend the meaning of the symbols because the symbols more often than not inform the

Malaysia Trip

313 words - 2 pages differences of celebrating the Independence Day on 31 August 1957 and today is the spirit of independence. The new generations do not know how to appreciate the freedom that they have today. For instance, people nowadays do not understand the real meaning of the historic day. In addition, it can be seen that many teenagers nowadays prefer to have a party to celebrate the day. In contrast, people in the past had a strong spirit for independence. As a

Irony

668 words - 3 pages Irony 1. Definition There are innumerable definitions of irony, but all of them have in common the following notions: * the opposition of the word’s contextual meaning to its general meaning * mockery as the major goal of irony Irony is… * (from Ancient Greek εἰρωνεία (eirōneía) meaning “dissimulation, feigned ignorance”) a trope based on direct opposition of the meaning to the sense. (J.M. Skrebnev) * a stylistic device

Conceptual Analysis

484 words - 2 pages . To have a certain thing as the subject of one’s thoughts C. To consider something as a possible action, choice, etc. D. To have consideration or regard for someone E. To esteem a person or thing as indicated 3. Determine which of these meanings could be relevant in the question. * I think that A is the meaning of the word most commonly intended when this question is asked. * B, C, D, and E, those meanings could be

Ayer

1149 words - 5 pages they believed that unless something can be empirically proven then it doesn’t exist meaning that it has no meaning. However one issue with this theory is that you cannot prove something that isn’t of sight for example historical statements and emotional statements. This also applies to religious statements because god cannot be proven meaning his is not a physical being making him meaningless. However Ayer creates the weak verification principle and

Report

576 words - 3 pages -- McGarrity 3 Antonymy Reverses: one word undoes the movement suggested by the other raise/lower exhale/inhale expand/contract LING 200 -- McGarrity 4 Antonymy Converses: relational opposites, with two opposing points of view; the presence of X implies the presence of Y employer/employee send/receive buy/sell predator/prey LING 200 -- McGarrity 5 Lexical decomposition Analyzing a word’s meaning by breaking it down into its

Derrida

541 words - 3 pages Can’t we deconstruct Derrida’s own writing? In Differance, Derrida suggests that a given word’s meaning comes not from the word itself, but from its relationship with other words in the structural web, as well as from how it differs from those other words. (Interestingly, each of the words that give a given word its meaning are themselves only reflected in their structural relationship and difference from still other words). Further, Derrida’s

Related Essays

Mind Body And The Meaning Of Life Paper

1291 words - 6 pages Individual Assignment Week 2 Mind-Body and the Meaning of Life Paper Quandra Johnson Philosophy\ 443 October 28, 2013 Dr. Shaun Herness The religions of ancient Egypt have their history rooted in creation myths. These myths were derived from deification of mortals who were great rulers. The ruler, who would become the Egyptian Christ like figure, was known as King Horus. King Horus came from the Southern part of Africa with a

Rich Meaning Essay

845 words - 4 pages   Throughout this society we have many different meanings of word rich. Rome is rich with ancient ruins. The Mona Lisa is rich with artistic value. The Walton family is extremely rich. The last sentence is what many people hope and dream about. What is the meaning of rich? You can ask people what rich means to them, but you will find many different answers. I believe being rich is not just having material wealth, but also having inner

The Meaning Behind "The Road Not Taken"

902 words - 4 pages The meaning behind “The Road Not Taken” Laura M. Beck Liberty University English 102 September 26th 2011 Outline I. Symbolism II. Theme The paths and choices of life III. Mood and setting Choosing the right path a. One leads to eternal life b. One leads to destruction IV. Conclusion Choosing the right path makes all the difference. Thesis statement: This poem is a symbol of choosing which path we will take in

The Starbucks Meaning Essay

894 words - 4 pages into this media. Let’s start from the obvious. These refresher beverages give you energy. Energy to any and everything.at the beginning we see the barista at Starbucks shaking up one of the refresher beverages. The fusion of the mixture us like the building of energy. Once the drink is poured into M a r s h a l l | 2 the cup, we see a change in the scenery. The energy is exploding out. We see a mother take a sip of the drink and in the