This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Need Theories: Comparing Maslow, Alderfer, And Mcclelland

1226 words - 5 pages

19 July 2014
Need Theories: Comparing Maslow, Alderfer, and McClelland

Most theories of motivation revolve around the idea an employee’s needs influence their motivation. Needs are physiological or psychological scarcities that stimulate behavior therefore are necessary to live a healthy, productive lives both in personal and work lives. “If work is meaningless, then life comes close to being meaningless”(Maslow, Stephens Heil 39). These needs, whether weak or strong and are greatly influenced by environmental factors, thus causing human needs to vary over time and place. The general idea behind need theories of motivation is that unmet needs motivate people to placate them. On the ...view middle of the document...

At this point, staff members begin to seek a level of self-esteem from the competence level and seek recognition from their peers and management. At the top of the hierarchal pyramid is the self-actualization need. At this point, maximization of one’s full potential is achieved. This point cannot be reached until all other needs have been met. Podmoroff states, “Maslow’s work is often considered the foundation for which other motivation theories grew and many of these theorists support a downward cycle of employee motivation when particular need are not met”(26).
Clayton Alderfer developed the ERG Model, as an enhancement to Maslow’s model, focusing specifically on work related needs. His theory has three needs, existence needs, relatedness needs and growth needs, as opposed to the 5 for Maslow. The existence need can be related to the needs required to maintain a humane life. The relatedness needs focuses on social interactions and interpersonal relationships. Lastly, the growth need is the desire to be creative, self-confident, and productive, and engaged to the full abilities and obtain enhanced capabilities or skills. “ERG theory does not assume needs are related to each other in a stair-step hierarchy as does Maslow. Alderfer believes that more than one need may be activated at a time. Finally, ERG theory contains a frustration-regression component. That is, frustration of higher-order needs can influence the desire for lower-order needs” (Kreitner ch. 8).
David McClelland identified three needs, need for achievement, need for affiliation, and need for power, individuals have at differing levels. He argued that all of us experience these needs but at capricious points. “A person’s motivation and effectiveness in certain job functions are influenced by these three needs”(McClelland - Theory of Needs). Those who have a high need for achievement share three common characteristics: a preference for tasks of moderate difficulty, situations in which their performance is due to their own efforts, and a desire for more performance feedback on their successes and failures. Those with a high need for affiliation have a strong desire for approval and reassurance from others, a tendency to conform to the wishes of others when pressured by people whose friendships they value, and a sincere interest in the feelings of others. Finally, those with a high need for power seek to influence and direct others, exercise control over others, and maintain leader-follower relations.
Upon further comparisons, Alderfer does not disagree with Maslow's hierarchy of needs completely. He suggests that as more concrete needs are satisfied, less concrete need become more important. Instead of the five needs Maslow believes should be satisfied, Alderfer says there are only three important needs, and McClelland says there three differing needs than the others. Whereas Maslow's theory argues that individuals move up the hierarchy as a result of the...

Other Papers Like Need Theories: Comparing Maslow, Alderfer, And Mcclelland

Motivation Paper

647 words - 3 pages , persistence, and overcoming difficulties” (Nelson and Quick 157). They tend to outperform others and take great pleasure in the doing…in the work itself. Achievement-motivated individuals are goal setters who seek the middle ground. They are not risk-takers but rather aggressive realists (The Three Basic Approaches to Improving Productivity: David C. McClelland 2). Furthermore, people with a high need for achievement want feedback, specifically job

Biological And Humanistic Theories Essay

1623 words - 7 pages theory provides an understanding of individual’s basic needs and concentrates on accepting responsibility for one’s actions. Maslow believes in the basic goodness and respect of humans. Since free will was not a part of other theories, the humanistic theory was developed. The humanistic theory addresses free will and the meaning of our existence. Theorists do not agree on the actual definition of the humanistic theory, but four key elements

Psychology

287 words - 2 pages University of Phoenix Material Humanistic and Existential Personality Theories Worksheet Fill-in the Blank 1. Abraham Maslow proposed the __humanistic_______________ theory of personality. 2. According to Maslow, self-fulfillment and realization of one’s full potential are examples of __self actualization______________ needs. 3. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs proposes that ____basic________ needs must be satisfied before

Week 5

283 words - 2 pages University of Phoenix Material Humanistic and Existential Personality Theories Worksheet Fill-in the Blank 1. Abraham Maslow proposed the _________________ theory of personality. 2. According to Maslow, self-fulfillment and realization of one’s full potential are examples of ________________ needs. 3. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs proposes that ____________ needs must be satisfied before ____________ needs will become

Mod G Unit 2 Spelling

433 words - 2 pages May Concern." 6. Phenomenological- Term that decribes viewing a situation from the other person's point of view. 7. Regard- Pertaining to. 8. Dental Radiograph- X-ray of teeth. 9. Intrapersonal Conflict- Conflict within oneself when one is expected to perform a task that does not meet personal goals, values, beliefs, or expertise. 10. Humanistic Theories- Theory based on the works of Maslow and Rogers. 11. Complimentary Closing

My Perspective

263 words - 2 pages The perspective that I’m writing about that “fits” or is the closest to my own way of thinking is the humanistic theory. I chose to write about this because I agree with Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow in that people are generally motivated to improve or achieve the highest level of success that an individual can. Even though Carl Rodgers believed that the actualizing tendency applied to all organisms and not just humans, I figured he deserved

History Of Perfomance Technology

855 words - 4 pages to ensure organizational survival to the political and socioeconomic forces of their time. The death of an organization affects the livelihoods and well-being of employees and to an extension the geographical areas and the local economies which depend on an organization. Early responses to ensure organizational survival led to the pursuit of various psychological and economic theories of human behavior (International Society for Performance

Methodology

3329 words - 14 pages adapt to the seasonality in various areas, I made a desk research based on reading information related to the topics such as motivating employees, Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning and loyalty with customers. I will provide answers in question number 3 using appropriate theories and models. I will analyze motivation of employees by using Maslow´s hierarchy of needs, Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning by using STP-approach and

Theory

420 words - 2 pages an individual. Set realistic but challenging targets. Understand that progress itself motivates. Create a motivating environment. Provide relevant rewards. Recognise success. John Adair's work is in line with motivational theorists such as Maslow, McGregor and Herzberg. He emphasises the need for development of the team and team building. This can be achieved through team building events and using theories such as that of Belbin. Where Adair identifies the need, Belbin provides one of the tools.

Max0219

2594 words - 11 pages roles in all companies bringing uneven distribution of power. However if the task are well distribute the power will be even and employees will fill more comfortable getting better results. On the other hand, there are other theories described by Spatig that are related to her main topic “Fayol classical management theory”: a. McGregor theories X and Y: He assert, that Maslow theory is not believable. Human beings need to

Motivation In The Work Place

3081 words - 13 pages throughout the years. Many researchers had have researched many theories in order to understand "the human nature itself". Some of these theories have had a higher level of credibility and are easy to apply within the workplace and others on the other hand have simply failed. Some of the most noticeable researchers include; Abraham Maslow (hierarchy of needs), Douglas McGregor (Theory Y), Frederick Herzberg (two factor motivation

Related Essays

Organizational Behavior Essay

1877 words - 8 pages , performance-to-reward expectancy, and reward valences. ________________________________________________________________________ Need theories of motivation (Alderfer, 1972; Herzberg, 1968; Maslow, 1970; McClelland, 1976) attempt to explain what motivates people in the workplace. Expectancy theory is more concerned with the cognitive antecedents that go into motivation and the way they relate to each other. That is, expectancy theory is a

Classification Of Motivation Theories Essay

9107 words - 37 pages cation A Classification of Motivation Theories (Content vs. Process) Motivation theories can be classified broadly into two different perspectives: Content and Process theories. Content Theories deal with “what” motivates people and it is concerned with individual needs and goals. Maslow, Alderfer, Herzberg and McCelland studied motivation from a “content” perspective. Process Theories deal with the “process” of motivation and is concerned with

Organisation Behaviour And Motivation Essay

3939 words - 16 pages encompasses esteem needs and self-actualization of Maslow‟s theory. This is a need consisting of self-improvement; develop intrinsic motivation for task through accomplishments; compete meaningful task and be creative. Unlike Maslow, Alderfer contends an individual may be motivated by two ot three need category at the same time where one need appears more dominant than the other. This is known as the „frustration-regression process‟ whereby if an

How Employee Motivation Affects Employee Retention And Other Behaviors Within Organizations

2322 words - 10 pages relationships. Achievement theories propose that motivation and performance vary according to the strength of one’s need for achievement (Kreitner, 1998). McClelland’s research supported an analogous relationship for societies as a whole revealing that a country’s level of economic development was positively related to its overall achievement motivation (McClelland, 1961). Equity Theory Equity theory recognizes that individuals are concerned not