Reflective Review

6167 words - 25 pages


As they are intervening in complex human systems, capacity-development practitioners need to be flexible, adaptable and willing to learn from what they do. An important source of learning in real time is the processes and results of monitoring and evaluation (M&E). Bruce Britton explains M&E activities as they are commonly pursued and explores creative ways in which practitioners can use them for personal learning and selfreflection. He also provides suggestions on how this can be done under non-conducive organizational conditions.

Monitoring and Evaluation for Personal Learning
Bruce Britton

By three methods we may learn wisdom: first, by reflection, which is ...view middle of the document...

In doing so they can undermine the self-confidence of the practitioners involved. The negative effects of this are experienced in different ways: at an organizational level in terms of frustration over unachieved goals and at an individual level as poor performance and de-skilling. However, there is another way of viewing deviation from plans, namely by using divergence as experiencebased opportunities for reflection. In other words, the unpredictability and fluid nature of capacity development can be viewed not as a failure of planning but as an indication of the need for adaptability and an opportunity for learning. As capacity development practitioners become more experienced, they develop a deepening understanding of the complexity of the issues with which they are working. Using the insights generated through reflection, advisers can become more adaptable and flexible in dealing with the unexpected challenges and problems that arise in day-to-day work with clients. So, how can practitioners accelerate the pace at which they deepen their mastery of capacity development? One powerful way is through experience-based learning processes such as shadowing, coaching and action-learning. Unfortunately, not all practitioners have access to these structured experiential learning opportunities. However, practitioners can also develop their expertise using personal techniques for reflecting on and learning directly from their work. Using the formal feedback mechanisms of monitoring and evaluation is an important and often overlooked way to do so. This being said, using monitoring and evaluation in this way can be difficult because most of these systems are designed with other purposes in mind. The conventional view of monitoring and particularly evaluation sees them as processes that are used primarily for assessing performance and ensuring accountability, not for reflection and learning. Reasons for this are explored in detail in Chapter 21. Consequently, if monitoring and evaluation rigidly focus on performance management it may be necessary for the practitioner to ‘subvert’ these systems – in the sense of challenging and expanding their intended purpose – in order to maximize the learning opportunities they offer. This chapter examines how capacity development practitioners can use formal and informal monitoring and evaluation systems not only to assess progress towards intended outcomes but also, and just as importantly, for the purposes of self-improvement. In addition, by taking a creative approach to informal monitoring, practitioners can also create valuable opportunities for strengthening mutual support with colleagues. The rest of the chapter is organized as follows. We begin with a brief introduction to the monitoring and evaluation of capacity development initiatives, also discussed in more detail in Chapter 18. The chapter then focuses on what can be characterized as the conventional purposes and uses of both monitoring and


Other Papers Like Reflective Review

Pressure Ulcer Prevetion Essay

1729 words - 7 pages her advice on research material and guidance she was glad to help, and give me a multitude of website names she found very help full in the past to produce leaflets and presentations. When I told her that I felt a bit fraudulent by using this reflective account to review a skill I have, in effect, been using for almost two decades. She quickly assured me that in her time as Tissue Viability Nurse she has meet many Nurses, who have been nursing

Coaching And Mentoring Essay

3515 words - 15 pages some negativity towards the refocus on coaching due to the bad experience they have previously experienced with external coaches, it could be suggested that Foundation Design are displaying double-loop learning by changing the method in achieving the goal rather than repeating existing methods (Argyris, 1991). It could also be suggested that the CEO has carried out reflective practice which has supported double-loop learning. Another important

Mgmt591 Course Project

691 words - 3 pages exclude from the paper. Literature Review 40 You must address at least six scholarly resources in this section. Approach this section as a mini "book report" on each of the reference sources that significantly informed your analysis and proposed solutions. Give the reader an encapsulated review of what information you found most relevant to your research. You may have found conflicting opinions/theories related to your topic area. Identify and


789 words - 4 pages exhaustive but includes SAAFA, Padre, Platoon Staff, Soldiers Review Board, Services Education Centre etc. . 6. An important role for you as a teacher is being organised . 7. You should be reflective in your teaching programme, learn from mistakes as well as success. As a teacher within this establishment you will be expected to promote certain responsibilities. You should carry out further reading from the Staff Handbook to understand

Bla Bla

939 words - 4 pages of the salt. Review of Related Literature Alfredo Moser got the idea of a solar bottle bulb as he was figuring out a way to illuminate his workshop during one of the frequent power cuts. He realized that he can light up his workshop by hanging plastic bottles on the roof filled with water. With the rising costs of commodities, including electricity, I’m sure all of us are finding ways and means to reduce our expenses. Here is an

Financial Statement Analysis

1138 words - 5 pages Accounting Quality At the core, the annual reports must reflect a true and fair view of the company’s performance. However, the quality of the results presented is equally important. That is, the earnings reported must be reflective of the future earnings capacity of the company. This will enable investors to understand the core earnings of the firm and help in forecasting the performance of the company. If earnings is of a poor quality, it

Book Review

1359 words - 6 pages Business for the Glory of God: The Bible’s Teaching on the Moral Goodness of Business Book Review Nathan Minor Liberty University The book that is under review is “Business for the Glory of God: The Bible’s Teaching on the Moral Goodness of Business” by Wayne Grudem. It is a useful resource for looking at business from different prospects. First off, it addresses a view on relationships between business and religion. Secondly, it shows how

Case Study

2759 words - 12 pages Charter. The Team Charter is the framework that will guide your team in its work this semester. A strong Charter will result in achieving the highest possible goals in your philanthropic project. It will provide for the development of personal leadership. It will allow members to grow, to take risks to accomplish personal goals and to flourish. 1. As a team, you will review your individual Rokeach Values results and your results from the

Management Structure

1647 words - 7 pages still due to overloaded responsibilities. Introduction This essay is a reflective review and appraisal that has been put together to emphasis the importance of an organisational structure and how the effective management of a business could lead to business success. This topic has a massive impact on businesses as it takes a vital place in business success for example; the loss of a manager will potentially jeopardize the company, having no

Developing And Leading Teams

2355 words - 10 pages aimed at preventing childhood overweight and obesity should involve parents as important forces for change in their children's behaviours. Although I agree with this, we as health professionals need to understand how parents feel and think about obesity and its effects on health in order to help them change their behaviour, which in turn will influence their children. Therefore the purpose of this literature review is, due to the rising levels of

Supreme Court Rise To Power

3569 words - 15 pages the is sent back to the congress or senate for review if there is no agreement made then the bill is done away with. Once you get to the judicial branch you start to read you see the stipulations aren’t defined or spelled out. The judicial branch was first made of four judges which later became nine. Once the court makes a decision on a case or ruling it becomes written in stone. In the whole history of the court there has never been a ruling to be

Related Essays

Others Essay

1375 words - 6 pages [pic] The Reflective Learning Process One of the problems of "book learning", is the difficulty of trying to relate theory to practice. We might know the answers, but true understanding cannot be absorbed until the experiences have been captured, analysed and related to the environment in which we work. Experiential learning, can be useful to learners who want to use direct learning experiences in order to develop an understanding of a

Apple 1 Essay

1027 words - 5 pages | | | | | | | Literature review | | | | | | | Methodology | | | | | | | METHODOLOGY: Review and finalise topic and refine research. Write the chapter 1-introduction. Literature search and review. Write chapter 2 literature review. Research methodology research literature on methodology Design and pilot questionnaire/interview questions REFLECTION: RESEARCH PROPOSAL 90% 3500 WORDS. REFLECTIVE REPORT 10% 1000 WORDS. MAXIMUM 1500

Research Project Specification Essay

468 words - 2 pages guidance from their project supervisor.Students will:- * Modify their research proposal (previously generated) * Consider the ethics involved * Apply appropriate methodologies and data collection as required * Select and employ appropriate analytical tools * Draw appropriate conclusions * Make appropriate recommendations (depending on issue/problem) * Evaluate the research exercise for reflective purposes | Learning Outcomes

How To Write A Critical Literary Analysis Essay

805 words - 4 pages book review or summary of the book, you should not retell the story in your essay. Rather, you need to form a thesis about the piece of literature and then explain and support the thesis you have developed. Although you are not summarizing the plot when you write a literary analysis, you will need to pull elements from the plot when writing your literary analysis. For example, when providing an analysis, you will use information from the piece of