Research With Prisoners Essay

2488 words - 10 pages

The history of conducting research with prisoners has been problematic. As a group, prisoners have been a population of convenience; researchers knew where they were and would be, often for many years. In addition, prisoners lived under controlled conditions conducive to research. It was generally accepted to use prisoners as research subjects for testing medicines, drugs, and medical devices without regard to the risks, benefits, and rights of those individuals.
As documented in Acres of Skin: Human Experiments at Holmesburg Prison (Hornblum 1998), prisoners were used in lieu of laboratory animals to test the toxicity of cosmetics. In other experiments, prisoners were irradiated in ...view middle of the document...

• Identify issues related to accessing prison populations.
• Describe the regulatory obligations of an Institutional Review Board (IRB) reviewing prisoner research.
Defining Prisoner
Part 46.303 of Subpart C (Protection of Human Subjects 2009) defines a prisoner as follows:
Prisoner means any individual involuntarily confined or detained in a penal institution. The term is intended to encompass individuals sentenced to such an institution under criminal or civil statute, individuals detained in other facilities by virtue of statutes or commitment procedures which provide alternatives to criminal prosecution or incarceration in a penal institution, and individuals detained pending arraignment, trial, or sentencing.
Included in this definition are those individuals in hospitals or alcohol and drug treatment facilities, who are under court order. Individuals in work-release and house arrest programs also qualify as prisoners. Individuals on parole are not considered prisoners. The definition applies to both minors and adults.
Research Allowed Under the Federal Regulations
The regulations at 45 CFR 46.306 (Protection of Human Subjects 2009) allow prisoners to be involved in four categories of research. Most social and behavioral sciences research falls into the first two categories:
1 Study of the possible causes, effects, and processes of incarceration, and of criminal behavior, provided that the study presents no more than minimal risk and no more than inconvenience to the subjects.
2 Study of prisons as institutional structures or of prisoners as incarcerated persons, provided that the study presents no more than minimal risk and no more than inconvenience to the subjects.
3 Research on conditions particularly affecting prisoners as a class (for example, vaccine trials and other research on diseases such as hepatitis and HIV which are more prevalent in prisons than elsewhere; and research on social and psychological problems such as alcoholism, drug addiction, and sexual assaults).
4 Research on practices, both innovative and accepted, which have the intent and reasonable probability of improving the health or well-being of the subjects. Studies that require the assignment of prisoners to control groups in which they may not benefit from the research may need federal-level review.
Examples of social and behavioral sciences research in the categories listed above include:
• Age at first arrest as a predictor of adult criminal history
• Effects of overcrowding on prison populations
• The influence of prison-awarded incentives (such as promotions in custody level) on retention in substance abuse treatment programs
• The use of true crime/detective stories as bibliotherapy
• Social support systems in prisons
• The functioning of pseudo-families in prison
Designing Prison Research
Consent Issues
Free Choice
Informed consent requires the ability to choose freely, without coercion and without undue influence. Because the autonomy...

Other Papers Like Research With Prisoners

Racial Disparities Essay

2051 words - 9 pages percent of defendants sentenced in federal court for crack offences are African-American. Criminologist William Chambliss suggest that blacks are more frequently viewed as suspects, pulled over and targeted by raids. I think racial profiling involving law enforcement plays a bigger role in the disparities than people give them credit for. It begins with law enforcement, and ends with the judicial system. In a survey conducted in Volusia County

Karapatan Essay

941 words - 4 pages enforced disappearances Freedom for all political prisoners Justice for all victims of human rights violations A stop to the militarization of the country-side and the forcible displacement of peoples and communities d A stop to the demolition of urban poor houses and communities as well as the violent dispersal of workers’ picketlines d An end to attacks on civil liberties and people’s rights KARAPATAN Alliance for the Advancement of People’s


845 words - 4 pages LUBS1755 Business and Society (Combined) and LUBS1765 Business and Society (Social Theory) 2013/14 Seminar 4: Feminism Week 8 for 1765 and Week 9 for 1755 Key reading: McDowell, L. (2010) ‘Capital culture revisited: sex, testosterone and the city’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 34(3): 652-8. Additional readings: Gottfreid, H. (2006) ‘Feminist Theories of Work’, in Korczynski, M. Hodson, R. and Edwards, P. [Eds

Adsf Asfsa Dsaf

5758 words - 24 pages expedited reviewer does not approve, the study must go to the full board. Minimal risk research not in exempt or expedited review categories Research that is more than minimal risk Certain research with vulnerable populations (children, pregnant women, prisoners) Exempt    Expedited    Full Board   IRB Tool: Exempt and Expedited Categories Comparison Chart .111 Regulatory Criteria Subject Selection Vulnerable

Http: //Imlportfolio.Usc.Edu/Ctcs505/Foucaultpanopticism.Pdf

3949 words - 16 pages training for released prisoners (88%). Finally, most Americans (77%) agreed that the expansion of after-school programs and other crime prevention strategies would lead to long-term savings by reducing the need for prisons. An equal proportion of the American public believed that treatment programs for drug offenders would save money. Indeed, it would seem that Americans are looking for effective ways of addressing the real problems of crime, with a

Dissection Paper

1124 words - 5 pages arguments as to whether it is necessary for the student's education or inhumane. Therefore, this act should stop completely. Through my research I have found that it is both necessary for learning and it can be inhumane. At which, another choice or alternative should always be available for the student who is not willing to dissect and at no expense to their grade.Many advances in medicine and in the understanding of how organisms function have been

Hotel Rwanda

801 words - 4 pages HOTEL RWANDA HISTORY QUESTIONS Use history handouts given & internet research ( short answer questions) 1. What is a "culture of impunity" and how does it relate to the "rule of law"? 2. Could the Rwandan genocide have been stopped? 3. Who is to blame for the Rwandan genocide of 1994? 4. Both the citizen who killed his Tutsi neighbour with a machete and the government leader who convinced his people to do the killing but did not


2315 words - 10 pages victims screamed with pain as their bodies froze” (Bekier 5). Since the end of World War II the results for the hypothermia experiment have been made available to medical researchers. A researcher on hypothermia, Dr. Robert Pozos’, researched the different methods of rewarming frozen victims because of the cold. He speculated that the effects of the cold would be seen on a human at freezing temperatures. When finding other peoples research, the only

Organ Trafficking In Moldova

1202 words - 5 pages protect Moldovans from illegal organ harvesting syndicates. " - In fact, many high ranking people from the government's own party are deeply involved in the flesh business," says a local journalist. He claims to have spoken to victims and have photos of dead children with missing organs. Journalists at Kommersant Plus, a Moldovan newspaper, received death threats after one of them started research on an article aimed at exposing government

Misconceptions About Islam And Muslims

2071 words - 9 pages over a billion people worldwide, has been subject to criticism and skepticism. However, any true believer of this faith should be aware of the possible misconceptions in order to shed light to others who may have their doubts about Islam. This paper will clear up a few misconceptions to those who may be unfamiliar with Islam and Muslims, and even to those Muslims who may not have a strong religious foundation or background. Allah is Only the

Case Study Data Breaches And Regulatory Requirements

1570 words - 7 pages facility. The Application Development Group helps The Department of Corrections management and operations in house development of applications, databases, research and statistical reports, compliance with federal reporting, the main goal is to convert paper processes. The Division of Security and Training provides maintenance of security and computer training. The Department of Corrections is in compliance with Criminal Justice Information

Related Essays

Prisoners With Special Needs Essay

917 words - 4 pages Prisoners with Special Needs Roy Briston CJA/234 February 18, 2014 Prisoners with Special Needs There are many inmates in prisons that have different special needs. Some of these needs are based on whether the inmates are male or female. Males have some special needs to take care of their selves that females do not and vice versa. Then there are those who suffer from a mental illness. Their special needs are much different than those

Feminise Essay

416 words - 2 pages rench ethnographer Germaine Tillion, now aged 96, was in Algiers when the Nazis invaded France in June 1940. She had just completed five-and- a-half years of intensive research among Berber seminomads in the Aures moun- tains, at the edge of the Sahara. She had been so busv compiling their complete genealogies that she had lost track of Europe. There had been no newspapers in the remote mountains and no mail deliverM She

Prison Industrial Complex Essay

9124 words - 37 pages : “This summer, a cricket entered my yard; it [sic] looked to me like a companion. If a butterfly, or any other animal enters my cell, I never do it [sic] any harm” (cited Dumm 1987, 110). Research on the presence of companion animals in prison suggests that regular contact with non-human animals can have a profound impact on prison conditions, the rehabilitation of prisoners, and recidivism rates after release.xx Even in non-carceral situations, when

Eating Disorders Essay

2420 words - 10 pages eating disorders. Though according to researchers 90% of those tend to be females, but the number in males with eating disorders is constantly rising as well. (Eating Disorders: Anorexia and Bulimia. 21) Both the age of adolescence and early adulthood are significant factors and have led to the fact that the majority of the research reports only target the female population in adolescence. The thing that also plays in major role in appearances is