This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Sample Critique Of Movie Review

663 words - 3 pages

Andy Patrick
English 2001
Mr. David Harris
18 November 2011
Cultural Review: Gangs of New York

In his review, Roger Ebert gave the film Gangs of New York, directed by Martin Scorsese, a three and a half star rating out of four and made both positive and negative comments of the movie. Although he gave it a favorable review he also said it was “very good but not great”(Ebert). The problem with Ebert’s review is that he does not review the details of the movie, such as the acting or the set or soundtrack, but critiques the movie only as a whole after a long summary of the film. Gangs of New York was a great movie with a couple of fantastic performances by both Daniel Day-Lewis and Leonardo DiCaprio, and Roger Ebert’s review did not do it justice.
The main problem that I have with Ebert’s review is that he ends with an entire paragraph that compares Gangs of New York with Scorsese’s ...view middle of the document...

Day-Lewis plays Bill perfectly, and his personality is so unique in the film. He is sinister and wicked but also witty and humorous, and he is crazy but smart enough to make others believe he is the voice of reason. Dicaprio’s character, Amsterdam, is also written and played very well. Ebert was right to say that he is “not the most colorful person on the canvas” and that because he is slightly dull he magnifies the eccentricity of the other characters.
The one main problem with the film is Jenny, played by Cameron Diaz, who is the independent tough woman and love interest of Amsterdam. It is mostly Cameron Diaz that I had a problem with because she was not convincing as that type of character. When I watched the movie I believed it, but when Diaz was on screen I was watching her act. The other problem is that she is just too attractive. One of the great things about the movie was its authenticity, but Cameron Diaz is just too sexy to be living in the slums of New York in the 1840s. She is also just not the best actress, and with such a great cast surrounding her it was very noticeable.
As far as Scorsese movies go I do believe that Gangs of New York is one of the greatest. Ebert did not think it was in the top ranks of his masterpieces, but in my opinion it is a lot better of a movie than some of his others such as Casino or The Departed. It surprises me that Gangs of New York does not get brought up more often in conversations about people’s favorite movies or that Bill the Butcher does not get brought up as one of the greatest villains in film. The movie did not do anything new or spectacular cinematically or change anything about how movies are made, but it is certainly a great story that is told very well with fantastic characters that is entertaining from start to finish.

"Gangs Of New York :: Rogerebert.com :: Reviews." Rogerebert.com :: Movie Reviews, Essays and the Movie Answer Man from Film Critic Roger Ebert. Web. 18 Nov. 2011. <http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20021220/REVIEWS/212200304/1023>.

Other Papers Like Sample Critique Of Movie Review

Bafuguwahs Essay

496 words - 2 pages FINAL ORAL/PRACTICAL PRESENTATION OF A PATIENT CASE & COMPREHENSIVE TREATMENT SESSION Students will work in groups of two to three to prepare and present a comprehensive one hour presentation of a patient case, treatment program, and sample treatment session. The case will be assigned by the instructor. The following patient information will be provided: ** This profile must accompany the informative packet.** 1. medical diagnosis

Shakespeare In Love Essay

563 words - 3 pages Movie Critique: Shakespeare in Love On Monday, April 23,2012 I watched a movie called Shakespeare in Love. This movie is fictional written about the great writer and poet, William Shakespeare. The story is of a young William Shakespeare barely making ends meet and trying to write a play for the local theatre. However, Shakespeare is suffering from writer's block, and is seeking inspiration by having a muse. A muse is a power, in this case a

Hitch Review

552 words - 3 pages Hitch Review We look forward to different types of entertainments to get a good laugh or have a good time. Specifically movies are used as a major part of entertainment Hitch, for example, came out in 2005. It produced by Will smith, James Lassiter, and Teddy Zee. This movie was directed by Andy Tennant. What were the most interesting things and what didn’t really appeal have an important role on the outcome of the movie production. The

Project Examples For Sampling And The Law Of Large Numbers

3019 words - 13 pages pilot weight is not within the confidence interval. The sample average of 175 pounds is estimated to have a margin of error of +/- 3%, or +/- 5.2 pounds [+/- 2.4 kg]. ©Copyright 2010 John C Goodpasture Page 6 Acknowledgement The author is indebted to Dr. Walter P. Bond, Associate Professor (retired) of Florida Institute of Technology for suggestions and peer review. Appendix Proportional category data Confidence Interval, proportions

Art103

342 words - 2 pages portfolio, I will be looking for: • thorough, complete, and detailed answers to all of the above questions • evidence of thought and self-reflection • well-organized presentation * Your pieces of writing can be from ANY writing you have done in or for the class, including the three formal papers (personal narrative, article outline/summary/critique, research paper), in-class assignments (free writing, summarizing, peer review, mapping), journal entries, and homework (summaries, responses to readings).

Sihite’S Family Literacy Practices

4179 words - 17 pages also to other researchers who want to do more in-depth research to develop literacy practices in family. It is expected that the findings of the study would motivate or encourage the readers to do literacy practice in their families. CHAPTER TWO REVIEW OF LITERATURE 2.1 Literacy Hussain (2005) stated that: “Literacy is a fundamental human right and a prerequisite to the empowerment of the individual and development of society. Literacy is at

The Missing Film Critique

996 words - 4 pages History 398 Fall Semester 2011 Film Critique In the movie The Missing a woman named Maggie and her two daughters Lilly and Dot live on a plot of land, that they farm in New Mexico in 1885. Maggie is a doctor and lives with her boyfriend who helps run the farm. A stranger visits to seek treatment for a wound and it is Maggie’s estranged father. Her father left her family when she was young to be with the Indians. Maggie does not like her

The Fourth Amendment In The News

659 words - 3 pages judicial review to decide if laws by the executive branch and legislative branch are constitutional. The U.S. Supreme Court also uses its power of judicial review to analyze various lower court decisions for the appropriate application of inherent constitutional rights. This news article analysis will discuss the requirements for search warrants, arrest warrants, and warrant exceptions in relation to probable cause under the Fourth Amendment. In a

Citation Help

6331 words - 26 pages ) ....................................................................... 23 Center for Writing Excellence © 2009 University of Phoenix, Inc. All rights reserved 4 Books A book with one author A book with one author could be formatted in any of the following ways: In-Text Citation Sample 1 According to Lunsford (2009), new writing spaces created by technology require the writer to focus on the audience and on the writing purpose more than ever before

District 9 Vs Ouat

1399 words - 6 pages : the harmful divisions that occur within groups. Ultimately, the housemaid’s actions are not reflections of her own inherent racism, but the product of apartheid. In spite of the fact that both texts critique the apartheid, one is a movie critiquing on what keeps us treating other people inhumanely isn’t tested by treating people that we admire with dignity, but treating people we don’t understand with the same level dignity

Reading

463 words - 2 pages senior criminologist, discusses the tailoring of the inmate to the appropriate facility. Finally, Orlando Boyce, a sergeant at the fictional Deephall correctional facility, discusses measures that could conceivably make prison life effective and thus decrease the likelihood of recidivism. Write a three to four (3-4) page paper in which you: 1.Outline your findings from your review of the file of Kris, for whom Robert is considering

Related Essays

Movie Critique Of Constantine Essay

1702 words - 7 pages Movie Critique of Constantine HUM/150 Movie Critique of Constantine Constantine is a horror movie that rest on supernatural concepts. The film is about a chain smoking psychic, John Constantine, who exorcises demons and has a disdain for life. He teams up with another psychic, Angela, who has lost her twin sister, Isabel, to suicide. Together they find out her motives of suicide tie into a large sinister plot to get Satan’s

Business Essay

408 words - 2 pages To complete this assignment, you will read the attached article and write a 1-2 page, single-spaced summary of the article. In your review, discuss the following: * Summary of article: what was the research question the authors were interested in? What was their hypothesis? How did they study it? Briefly discuss the methods and results. * Critique: How does this study fit in with what you have learned about attachment and development

Blooms Questions Essay

455 words - 2 pages ...? • Can you explain what must have happened when...? • How is ... similar to...? • What are some of the problems of...? • Can you distinguish between...? • What were some of the motives behind...? • What was the turning point in the game? • What was the problem with...? Evaluating Useful Verbs Sample Question Stems Assess Justify Critique Judge • Is there a better solution to...? • Judge the value of... • Can you defend your position about

Research Critique Part 1 Essay

725 words - 3 pages Research Critique Part 1 Jenna Franz Grand Canyon University Introduction to Nursing Research NRS-433V Mary O'Connell September 5, 2013 Research Critique Part 1 This paper will critique a qualitative research study published in the Journal of Medical Ethics in 2004, By Dr Helen Aveyard, about how nurses manage patients who refuse nursing care procedures. The article explains how nurses view informed consent as not being essential to