This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Taking Development To People Is A Fallacy

2939 words - 12 pages

LESSON 7: CHARACRERISTICS OF AN EMPOWERED COMMUNITY 7.1 Introduction Other than its definition, we have also noted in previous lectures three important facts about empowerment, and these are: a) Empowerment is a process that takes time; b) Every human experience has a contribution to make towards that empowerment; and that c) While individuals and communities are at the end of the day responsible for their own empowerment, external inputs too have value. In this lecture we will be discussing characteristics of an empowered community over time; community’s role in its own development; and also the role of external input, especially that of people’s government, in this empowerment process.
...view middle of the document...

Perhaps we are all too busy “with living” our normal lives – and for some this living is such struggle to make ends meet that the kind of thinking proposed here would look a mere luxury. Others may be living in what psychologists call a “state of denial”, that is the state of refusing to accept one’s reality. Perhaps a review of Freire’s three levels of awareness – levels at which we all fall – might help us clarify our realities to some extent. a) Do those at the magic level of awareness know that although they look so dependent and that their “bosses” seem and pose to be powerful that these bosses are also totally dependent on them? Do they know that if united they have power no system can withstand? b) Do those at the naïve level of awareness accept that – though welleducated and certainly crucial to the life of the organizations in which they work – they are mere servants of faceless and brutal forces and systems and that they are also dispensable? Do they also accept that due to their privileged positions as managers in these “foreign” establishments, one of their key responsibilities is to empower their subordinates to also climb the ladder? c) Do those at the critical level of awareness accept that they too still have a lot to learn? Yet, for them, if they worked in unity and not as lone do-gooders, the sky is the limit, their possibilities are limitless and that together they could turn this world around? At whatever level, this understanding and acceptance of one’s reality, is the first step in a journey to empowerment. 7.3.2 The factors that shape our reality An empowered community should have the ability to identify the following two crucial factors that shape their reality: • its historical setting; and • the resultant social/cultural/economic system in which the community finds itself. Historical Setting A community needs to understand its history – past and also recent – and how this has shaped its reality. Let us take us Africans as an example of such a community in search of its reality. a) It would be naïve to dismiss colonialism (sometimes even the centuries ago slavery) when considering the African reality. That history has been an important factor in shaping not only our economic situation and relations between and among Africans and also with other human beings, but even more crucially these past forces have also greatly influenced how we take ourselves – contributing especially to the reduced self-esteem as a people; looking down on our institutions, religion and culture; and also the wholesale adoption and love of anything foreign. b) Our reality as Africans is also shaped by the way we have behaved as nations in the recent past, say, since independence beginning with Ghana in late 1950s. While this reality could not escape the influence of our past history and also interference from external sources, it is the greed and incompetence by our leadership at various levels that have been responsible for the...

Other Papers Like Taking Development To People Is A Fallacy

Charles Kettering, The Famed Us Electrical Engineer And Inventor Said “A Problem Well-Stated Is Half-Solved.” One Of The Key Capabilities In Consulting Is To Develop A Good Understanding Of The...

3006 words - 13 pages psychologist to dissolve the problem which was to put ‘mirrors’ in the elevator lobbies. The reason for this is because the young psychologist did not see the problem as the service been slow but by seeing the people been bored of waiting. Although the problem was not solved, it has dissolved from a major problem, to a minor. In this case study, it makes you think that a major problem can be solved with a very simple but unique solution to please those

Using Material From Item A And Elsewhere, Assess The Claim That ‘The Main Function Of Education Is To Maintain A Value Consensus In Society’

899 words - 4 pages The role of education in society is seen by many different people in many different ways. This is due to the fact that different sociologists hold different and conflicting views. Functionalists tend to believe that society is based on a shared culture of similar values and norms; as Item A mentions ‘Schools play a vital role by socializing young people into these basic values.’ Whereas, a different approach to education is one of Marxists, who

Tok External Assessment Essay - Knowledge Gives Us A Sense Of Who We Are.” To What Extent Is This True In The Human Sciences And Ethics

1914 words - 8 pages solidity to identity. Language influences and gives rise to a sense of belonging because language is itself a universal medium of communication in exchanging ideas. In turn, cultural knowledge from generations is passed down to the next generation in local dialects. With the development of different societies, different cultures and languages integrate into a deeper part of humans. All in all, over time, such cultural acclimatization forms one’s

Using Material From Item A And Elsewhere, Assess The View That The Main Function Of The Education System Is To Reproduce And Legitimise Social Inequalities. (20 Marks)

541 words - 3 pages Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the view that the main function of the education system is to reproduce and legitimise social inequalities. (20 marks) The education system is one of the most influential institutions in our society, as it 'breeds' children knowledge and skills from a very young age (4-5) all the way to young adulthood (16-18), through set lessons or through the hidden curriculum. Education is said to supply a


340 words - 2 pages the answer is bandwagon argument because here the fallacy is committed by threat of rejection by one's peers is substituted for evidence in an argument. On my fourth question correct answer is Straw Man here the fallacy is made upon the misinterpretation of Mr. Equalminded's idea’s or position. My fifth answer was also correct where there was a fallacy of appeal to force. Where coercion was made by the speaker. On my sixth answer the correct

Categorizing Fallacies Assignment

311 words - 2 pages Categorizing Fallacies Assignment CRT/205 Due: 7/10/11 1. Example: TV commercial –“This is your brain. These are drugs. This is your brain on drugs.” During this commercial it shows pictures of the difference between your brain on drugs and not on drugs. Type of Fallacy: Scare Tactics Explanation: This is a scare tactic because it tries to frighten kids or even adults to not do drugs. The commercial uses eggs to show the negative


1622 words - 7 pages dictators”. The statement that aid fosters corruption also ignores the potential that aid can be used to fight corruption by enabling a strong civil society to act as a watchdog on the government. There are already examples of this taking place in Africa. Fallacy 4 – That HIV in Africa is a result of Sexual Promiscuity This, our final fallacy, ignores one glaring fact. The glaring fact is that HIV transmission isn’t the result of sex as such


726 words - 3 pages answers the question that is followed after the answer. * Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc This fallacy assumes that a second event is the resultant of the first event always. For example: The only policy that effectively reduces public shootings is right-to-carry laws. Allowing citizens to carry concealed handguns reduces violent crime. In the 31 states that have passed right-to-carry laws since the mid-1980s, the number of multiple-victim public

Same Sex Issues

1266 words - 6 pages , religious and past moral beliefs are not the only factors affecting peoples decisions against same sex marriage. People like Evangelical Church Alliance, Rev. Robert Schnck, and Larry Cirigano fall under the ethnocentric fallacy. Ethnocentric Fallacy is the idea that our beliefs and behaviours are right and true, while the other people are wrong or misguided, and ethnocentrism is defined as the tendency to judge the beliefs and behaviours of other

Developing A Missile: The Power Of Autonomy And Learning

1469 words - 6 pages motivate his team to accomplish the goal. He mostly applied a participative and delegative approach. This was clearly demonstrated by actively listening to his staff and allowing them to make decisions and that were willing to accepting responsibility. According to, a fallacy is defined as a false notion, a statement or an argument based on a false or invalid inference, incorrectness of reasoning or belief; erroneousness, or

The Lack Of Jobs In America

1451 words - 6 pages Recession, or the global recession of 2009. However it’s more commonly known name is the Great Recession, resulting in many American home-owners losing their houses, due to housing market correction and subprime mortgage crisis. Few years back, young couple newlywed went through to purchasing a new home to form a family in. Not knowing that their mortgage rate was about to increase taking an abrupt down turn, forcing the young newlywed couple to home

Related Essays

Is Syracuse A Good City To Live In?

367 words - 2 pages Syracuse, a medium-sized city with about 1.45 million inhabitants, has been ranked the fourth in the top 10 American cities to raise a family in 2010 . Located in Central New York, it is an economic and educational hub of this region, providing comfortable living and good education for local people as well as international students from all over the world. When it comes to see how it wins the title of top 10 city to raise a family, the

A Gun Or A Piece Of Chalk: Is Giving Guns To Teachers The Answer?

1414 words - 6 pages than one in a million” (Lawrence). However, the general overreaction in light of these recent events means that people who have children will act on that reaction rather than the correct thing to do. Some people believe that the correct response to these tragedies is to arm the teachers who populate the school. The general consensus is that by arming a few teachers randomly in the school who volunteer to carry, then if an armed gunman comes into

'virtue Ethics Offers A Refreshing Approach To Morality But Its Main Weakness Is That It Is Too Vague.' Discuss

1151 words - 5 pages virtue ethics ethics is perhaps too vague. In theory an ethical ideology should provide humans with some kind of clear moral compass for acting in a principled manner, according to a specific guideline. Since virtue ethics is so ambiguous and interpretable there may be discrepancies between people attempting to follow it. By the same token virtue ethics is also a subjective system as it gives no specific advice on how to act in certain situations

Scenario Of An Employee Who Is Dissatisfied With Her Work Environment Work Ethic, And Needs To Find A Way To File A Formal Complaint With A Government Agency

663 words - 3 pages Abstract In this paper, I will be providing a response to a scenario of an employee who is dissatisfied with her work environment work ethic, and needs to find a way to file a formal complaint with a government agency. Work Ethic Compare and contrast the rights of employees and the responsibilities of employers in the United States and Europe. The United States and Europe have strong laws that protect employees. In the United States