The Man Who Can't Be Move

2891 words - 12 pages

Beyond the Individual Social Antimony in Discussions of Piaget and Vygotsky
Michael Cole, University of California, San Diego James V. Wertsch, Washington University, St. Louis Ever since the publication of the first translation of Vygotsky's Thought and Language (reborn as Thinking and Speech 25 years later) there has been an ongoing debate about the relationship between the ideas of Vygotsky and Piaget. In the brief space available, we have no interest in arguing the virtues of one man's ideas over the other. Instead, we will suggest that by and large commentators on the differences between these two thinkers have placed too narrow an emphasis on their ideas about the primacy of ...view middle of the document...

114)
Second, Vygotsky, contrary to another stereotype, insisted on the centrality of the active construction of knowledge. This insistence is reflected in 1

passages such as the following, which, ironically, Vygotsky wrote as part of a review and critique of Piaget's account of egocentric speech:

Activity and practice: these are the new concepts that have allowed us to consider the function of egocentric speech from a new perspective, to consider it in its completeness ... But we have seen that where the child's egocentric speech is linked to his practical activity, where it is linked to his thinking, things really do operate on his mind and influence it. By the word things, we mean reality. However, what we have in mind is not reality as it is passively reflected in perception or abstractly cognized. We mean reality as it is encountered in practice (1987, pp. 7879). Vygotsky's strong assumptions about the active individual are reflected in his focus on practices such as speaking and thinking and are the focus of an extended treatment in Zinchenko (1985). One reaction to the realization of this complementarity of active individual and active environment is to make coconstructionism the basis of theorizing: there is both an active child and an active environment (Valsiner, 1993; Wozniak, 1993). We certainly subscribe to that. However, what gets left out of such discussions, and the element we want to emphasize, is the essential presence of a third factor in the process of co- construction: the accumulated products of prior generations, culture, the medium within which the two active parties to development interact.

The Primacy of Cultural Mediation
Cultural-historical psychology as formulated by scholars representing many national traditions begins from the assumption that there is an intimate connection between the special environment that human beings inhabit and the fundamental, distinguishing, qualities of human psychological processes. The special quality of the human environment is that it is suffused with the achievements of prior generations in reified (and to this extent materialized) form. This notion can be traced back to at least Hegel and Marx (1845/1947) and is found in the writings of cultural-historical psychologists from many national traditions (Dewey, 1938; Durkheim, 1912; Leontiev, 1932; Luria, 1928; Stern, 1916/1990); Vygotsky, 1929). For example, John Dewey wrote that:

... we live from birth to death in a world of persons and things which is in large measure what it is because of what has been done and transmitted from previous human activities. When this fact is ignored, experience is treated as if it were something which goes on exclusively inside an individual's body and mind. It ought not to be necessary to say that
2

experience does not occur in a vacuum. There are sources outside an individual which give rise to experience (Dewey, 1938/1963, p. 39).
In their early writing on this subject, the...

Other Papers Like The Man Who Can't Be Move

Life Is Like The Movies Essay

1450 words - 6 pages "enlightened" people have to teach them, they shun them from society because they are scared, "If they could lay hands on the man who was trying to set them free and lead them up, they would kill him." (231) If they chose to accept the teachings, they too would be forced to go through the terrifying realization that everything they thought they knew was a lie. Plato is clearly stating that the masses are not strong enough to go through this

Suppression Of Individuality In Radiohead's, Fake Plastic Trees

802 words - 4 pages point in his life where he no longer accepts that he was "helping" the girls. The poignant line "gravity always wins" (besides being an obvious reference to image augmentation) brings attention to the eternal conflict between man's inventions (like society) and nature, and even goes as far as to suggest who will be the victor. She looks like the real thing She tastes like the real thing My fake plastic love But I can't help the

Joe Salatino, President Of Great Nothern American

1561 words - 7 pages to keep a job and is a breadwinner in order to be in a worthy relationship with me. This would be the beginning stage before we could move any further. If he proves that he is capable of meeting the requirements, then we can start a relationship. My man would have to have benefits because it doesn’t do a woman any good to get someone in the same state that she’s in. It would only lead to disaster depending on how ambitious that man is toward the

Relection Paper

2491 words - 10 pages my duty and attend my class in the afternoon. Good thing about their organization was their bond when they were working. Although they work seriuosly, sometimes they make their work lighter under pressure. The Director is a very kind man. He even told us if we were not contented with the grades we received we can tell him. On the other hand,my immediate supervisor Sir Art, is a homosexual. So my first impression of him was he might be quite

32423

4068 words - 17 pages dreaming when I'm awake Echos My minds at erase And my thoughts are done Ive been meaning to tell you this Since my lies begun The way I feel inside Reflects of the souls in your eyes Ive been meaning to tell you this All of my life To think of who I am Shows much of what you were too Slowly I realize  Ill be fine without you I gave you your chances And you just put them aside To find out too late Of who I am inside Show me

An Insperation For All

1078 words - 5 pages ...”’ (Thomas 132) The workers used Roberts mind against him to make him have a sense of hopelessness and sadness to deter him from wanting to drive. Second, the transportation employees kept a lot to themselves in hopes that Procter would want to get back on the road and drive, ‘"You can't really mean this," he said. "I must still be dreaming. This is all part of the test, isn't it?" The uniformed man said, "No, son, but you can try again

Utilitarism

2247 words - 9 pages appearing more feasible. A child in his intellectual capacity and manifestations, he has the animal passions of a strong man. Previous to his injury, although untrained in the schools, he possessed a well-balanced mind, and was looked upon by those who knew him as a shrewd, smart businessman, very energetic and persistent in executing all his plans of operation. In this regard his mind was radically changed, so decidedly that his friends and

Electric Zoo Festivel: New World Music

806 words - 4 pages EDM (electronic dance music). EDM has definitely grown popular in the past few years and provided the joy in life to millions of individuals worldwide. Electronic dance music was created in the 1980s in Detroit by a man called 'Frankie Knuckles”, who is also referred to as the 'Godfather of house'. He went to clubs and made and played music of his his mixer and technic turntables. He would reconstruct sounds by combining two tracks together and

Reeds Clothier

462 words - 2 pages capital policy with higher current assets than industry averages. Jim's customers were slow to pay A/R because they were friends and Jim was afraid of losing their business if he pressed them too hard. His sales overall might suffer if he losses these customers. But on the other hand if they turn out to be very loyal customers who understand that Reed's new policies are normal practice for most businesses, they might get on board with the new policies

Assignment

2808 words - 12 pages any more to the organization in the event that he has completely paid for his shares. His loss would be the sum he has paid for the shares. Lenders of the organization can't be make any move against the individuals. The veil of incorporation The strict use of the separate legal entity standard, has its weakness.There are situations even where third party endure. Where an organization is constrained limited liability organization, the

Kongen

1045 words - 5 pages today we're going to forget all about is. Of all days, on your birthday, you shouldn't be thinking about -"" (9. 85 - 87) The old man does not compare the war with peace - quite the reverse. By reading between the lines it is clear that the old man in a way has been influenced by living in a place with war. He does look forward to take the boy to a place without war - A place he compares with Eden and after he wakes up, he says: I think that the

Related Essays

The Man Who Ran Essay

349 words - 2 pages important role since the whole turning point of the storyline happens because of it. Mister Slemmon’s wealth and possessions cause everyone to be drawn to him. He himself allows women to treat him as an object rather than a person. Joe is extremely mesmerized by Slemmons. As soon as he hears of his presence, Joe can’t say enough about him to Missie May. She even gets to the point of exhaustion with Joe going on and on. “‘A new man done come heah from

Intersec Of Religon And Lit Essay

585 words - 3 pages that Trovald was alive in the first place. She was the one who made sacrifices for her family. She was the one who sat down for hours copying books so she could pay for the loan she borrowed for her husband's sake. As they say, a wife is the neck and the husband is the head. Without the neck the head can't move. Without Nora this trovald wouldn't even be alive.

This Man Essay

272 words - 2 pages THIS MAN I just met this man... A man that I thought will be like big bro to me... A type of shy boy... A quiet one... I can't even hear his voice in the crowd in our school... My lips form in a little curve whenever I see him... i don't know why... it's just like that he make me smile by just letting me to see him everyday.. He is like brother to me but I didn't even imagine he will be MORE THAN that! Got his number... texted him, chat

The Message Ind The Bottle Essay

435 words - 2 pages me that I have to move on, I begins to yell at them, and say that they are terrible parents. I know its wrong but I can't help it. I just fell that they have already giving up on him, but deep in my heart I know that it's true, I know that they love him, with all they heart. They just trying to find a way to move on, and that way is by raising my. I try to be a good girl and help them as mush as I can but I just miss my dad so mush. The