This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Organ Debate Essay

658 words - 3 pages

Taylor Nichols
English 1010
Mr. Fitzner
Summary-Response #1
February 7, 2016
Section A: Essay
The Organ Debate
MacKay made many points to support her argument on legalizing organ sales. Her first point was that the people who are currently donating organs, need money. She stated, “In third world countries, there are people willing to do anything for money. In such extreme poverty these people barely have enough to eat, living in shacks and sleeping on dirt floors” (MacKay 121). She continues to coincide with the donors, stating that they would basically be rewarded for donating an organ to someone in need. “We pay men for donating sperm, and we pay women for donating ova, yet we expect others to give away an entire organ for no compensation” (MacKay 121). As she said, we should treat organ sales like all other sales. If the transactions for organ sales were easier and beneficial to both parties, more people would be willing and to giving their organ away. ...view middle of the document...

They buyer and seller both need to know the procedures of the operation that will take place. Having more knowledge about their bodies will potentially help them make better decisions about their health.
The last point that MacKay makes is that it would be better and fairer to buyers. She says, “Without laws regulating live kidney transplants, these people are subject to possibly hazardous procedures. Instead of turning our backs, we have the power to ensure that these operations are done safely and efficiently for both the recipient and the donor” (MacKay 123). There are no documents in an illegal transaction, so if something were to go wrong nothing could be done. If the government took organ sales into their hands and regulated it, it would be easier and less of a stress for both, the buyer and the seller. The organ buyers and sellers would both have a better standing legally, because they would have documents and contracts in place for the transplant. This would make it easier for both parties if something were possibly to go wrong during an organ transaction.
In conclusion, there are many reasons why organ sales should be legalized. MacKay makes some interesting points, and now it is time for people to think about this topic upon themselves. This debate will most likely continue in the future. Think about it. Why not legalize organ sales?

Section B: Mechanical
1. MacKay, Johanna. "Organ Sales Will Save Lives." Norton Field Guide to Writing with Readings. 3rd ed. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc. 2013. 119-124. Print.
2. She stated, “In third world countries, there are people willing to do anything for money. In such extreme poverty these people barely have enough to eat, living in shacks and sleeping on dirt floors” (MacKay 121).
3. Johanna MacKay claims:
In a legal kidney transplant, everybody gains except the donor. The doctors and nurses are paid for the operation, the patient receives a new kidney, but the donor receives nothing. Sure, the donor will have the warm, uplifting feeling associated with helping a fellow human being, but this is not enough reward for most people to part with a piece of themselves. (121)
4. Regulating organ sales will provide both the seller and recipient safety. (MacKay 123)

Other Papers Like The Organ Debate

Aging Essay

5259 words - 22 pages greatest age differences appear among those who are seventy or older. General Intelligence In measures of intelligence, older adults display what is called the "classic aging pattern". Performance scores which measure problem solving ability tend to decline with age. Verbal scores which measure learning knowledge such as comprehension, arithmetic, and vocabulary, tend to remain stable. Considerable debate continues regarding the point at

Education Essay

8288 words - 34 pages . (Arrow, 1962; Metcalf et al., 1994; Williamson, 1985). There is, however, considerable debate within the HRM/D literature relating to the distinction, if any, which exists between these three activities and a fourth concept, learning. This question is of some significance because it is arguable that the extent to which an organization’s HR specialist views them as synonymous or distinct will significantly influence the way in which

Recruiting Process Of Dbbl

6632 words - 27 pages the Chairman and the Board for all operations/functions of the Bank. d) Management Committee (MANCOM): MANCOM is composed of the Managing Director, Deputy Managing Directors, Heads of Divisions/Departments/Units from Head Office and any other staff members who May be co-opted as required and designated by the Managing Director. MANCOM normally meets once a week to debate and decide the key issues confronting the bank in a collective manner


7817 words - 32 pages the intended audience understands. All audit staff should follow these objectives in all performance audit assignments. 2.7 Limits of Performance Audit While the internal audit will acquire every right to look at how well an organization is achieving its objectives, through Government laws this does not mean the Internal Audit can investigate all aspects of governments. The merits of what a government is aiming to do are for political debate

Lafarge S.A

2924 words - 12 pages presented in the case study. The analysis is centered on four Organizational behaviour concepts which include Values, Teamwork, Motivation and Creativity. The initiatives entail different strategies deployed by Lafarge in handling challenges encountered in either cases of business expansion or continuity at different plant locations. Care is taken to outline the activities and results associated with these initiatives and to show how these align


665 words - 3 pages Financial statements are the most common tool used for making business decisions. They consist of the balance sheet, income statement and statement of cash flows. The analysis tools used affect all aspects of a company not just a few. A systematic review of the resources a company used to achieve its mission is cost control. Cash flow should be kept at necessary levels for operations is one of the major benefits of cost control. It is a very

Analysis Of Operation Blue Star And Its Effects On The Gandhi Dynasty

934 words - 4 pages The period of time including and following Operation Blue star is considered a dark time in India and black spot in Indian history. It is a time Indian would rather forget, yet still to this day debate about. Was Indihar Gandhi correct in instating operation Blue Star, inflicting damage to the Golden temple, and being responsible for the killing of anywhere from 492 (official reports) to 1500 (estimates run as high as) civilians, which lead to

Regretful Decisions

930 words - 4 pages Regretful Decisions There are many individuals in a child’s life that helps mold them into a well-rounded adult. In most cases, this guidance comes from the child’s parents or other older, but in Sonny’s case, this guidance was expected from his older brother. In the short narrative, Sonny’s Blues, Sonny’s life was adversely affected by the decisions that his older brother made. The decisions that his brother made include leaving Sonny to

Jail Responsibilities

589 words - 3 pages Jail Responsibilities Monique Priorello September 23, 2012 One of the main responsibilities of a jail is to give the officers the correct “Police Correspondence” courses. This is because these courses give the officers the effective basic training that they need to do things such as; Writing of Memoranda, Police Reports, and Civilian Letters. What needs to be done first is make sure that there are NO errors. This means in


638 words - 3 pages Starbucks Nefertiti Wright Sangita Patel October 15, 2012 STARBUCKS 2 STARBUCKS - 1 - [no notes on this page]I. Job description a. Baristas II. Job specifications a. Duties III. Form of departmentalization STARBUCKS 3 Starbucks Starbucks have been named in the 100 best companies to work for. Starbucks has many job opportunities for people, which require the right job specifications. The employees create uplifting

Fight Club

917 words - 4 pages Fight Club is a story of the narrator’s struggle to gain control over his life. He is in search for an identity in the form of manhood. His masculinity is so repressed because of the absence of a father figure in his life. Because of this he creates Tyler, his alternate personality. Tyler is nothing like anyone the narrator has met, he is self assured and completely free. The narrators alternate personality Tyler Durden is the ultimate alpha

Related Essays

Should Animals Be Used For Scientific Research? Is It Humanly?

559 words - 3 pages , vaccines, organ transplantation, HIV treatments, heart- bypass surgery and many others? On the point of view, the use of animals is a controversial issue and many people sight it inversely, that is, the treatment of the animals and the reasoning behind testing on these animals if it’s for a greater cause or not. There are those who wonder if animals are treated realistically and whether they are cared for appropriately. However, some think it is the

Controversies Of Stem Cell Research Essay

1712 words - 7 pages or non-dividing state for years until activated by disease or tissue injury. Adult stem cells can divide or self-renew indefinitely, enabling them to generate a range of cell types from the originating organ or even regenerate the entire original organ. It is generally thought that adult stem cells are limited in their ability to differentiate based on their tissue of origin, but there is some evidence to suggest that they can differentiate to

Human Embryonic Stem Cells Essay

8387 words - 34 pages stem cells have generally been regarded as having the capacity to form only the cell types of the organ in which they are found, but recently they have been shown to exhibit an unexpected versatility (Ferrari et al., 1998; Bjornson et al., 1999; Petersen et al., 1999; Pittenger et al., 1999; Brazelton et al., 2000; Clarke et al., 2000; Galli et al., 2000; Lagasse et al., 2000; Mezey et al., 2000; Sanchez‐Ramos et al., 2000; Anderson et al., 2001

News Essay

4486 words - 18 pages archbishop will talk as needed. He will not keep quiet,” Archbishop Emeritus Oscar Cruz told the Inquirer over the phone on Sunday. “This man is intelligent and courageous. He will exercise his [pastoral duties] and will put into action his qualifications.” Cruz said. Cruz cited a pronouncement that Villegas made amid the debate on the RH bill last year, which he noted “had angered the Palace.” “My dear youth, contraception is corruption. The use of